Students face ‘conflict of interest’ in TEF submissions

New sanctions may make it harder for students to speak up, say representatives who fear judgements will be made on ‘shaky foundations’

Published on
November 16, 2026
Last updated
November 16, 2026
Source: Getty/Angela Allen

Students’ unions are worried that they will feel pressure to present a wholly positive picture in submissions to the revised Teaching Excellence Framework (TEF) because of the sanctions institutions could potentially face.

Plans to redraw the TEF, published late last month, aim to root out poor-value courses, including by introducing tough penalties for underperforming universities.

The “student experience” is one of the two categories in which institutions will receive a rating of gold, silver, bronze or “requires improvement” as part of the exercise, which will run for the first time next year.

Those receiving the lowest rating in student experience or student outcomes will have their student intake reduced by 10 per cent a year.

ADVERTISEMENT

The student experience will be judged on an institution’s National Student Survey (NSS) results, where available, and an independent student submission.

This will consist of a maximum 10-page reflection, coordinated and submitted by a “suitable student representative” nominated by the participating institution, who must act on behalf of the wider student body.

ADVERTISEMENT

While guidelines stress that the submission should be prepared independently of the university, Lewis Wilson, vice-president for higher education at the National Union of Students in England, said students’ unions’ reliance on their parent institutions will make the process difficult to navigate.

“What’s to stop a university from either giving unions loads of money [to incentivise a good submission] or threatening to take away their block grant?

“Maybe as a students’ union, you think you’re not going to be as hard as you could. It could be a conflict of interest when students’ unions are already chronically under-resourced.”

Noting that many unions are “on a tightrope budget-wise but also capacity-wise”, Wilson said “dedicating months and months to the TEF is not feasible right now”.

He feared that richer institutions might try to game the system by offering incentives to students, casting doubt on the accuracy of their metrics.

“Rich institutions right now that are maybe a little bit worried about getting a bronze…can now incentivise students to fill out the NSS. If you’ve been given a T-shirt, a can of Coke and a pack of sweets, you’re going to say: ‘Yeah, my uni is all right, actually.’”

With poorly performing universities potentially being denied tuition fee rises, Wilson said he feared that the exercise could create a “two-tier higher education system”.

ADVERTISEMENT

Institutions that lack the resources to invest in student services could see their scores slide, he said, and then “they’re caught in a trap of poverty” that will be difficult to escape.

ADVERTISEMENT

Unlike the previous TEF, the new student submission will take a “more structured approach”, according to Office for Students (OfS) proposals, “based around a common set of questions linked to each of the student experience criteria”.

Jack Medlin wrote the Keele University student submission for the TEF in 2021 and is now a policy officer at the Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education.

“Ultimately, it’s good to see that student submissions are still at the heart of proposals,” Medlin said. But there were also “some challenges”, he noted. “The OfS is looking at bringing in standard questions for students to answer. That’s good for providing that targeted scope, but there’s a need for balance for students to be able to speak to their unique experience.

“It’s important students at small providers, specialist providers and those without students’ unions are able to take part on equal terms as their contemporaries,” Medlin added.

He emphasised the importance of independence in the face of considerably harsher punishments for those rated poorly.

Providers must “support without steering” students, Medlin said, particularly “with the new weight [of] the TEF”.

The director of the ResearchPlus association of universities, Johnny Rich, said he welcomed the focus on getting student input but echoed fears that the overall approach would “build highly consequential judgements on shaky foundations”.

He said ResearchPlus would work with the OfS to design a way of measuring student experience via “benchmarked, value-added measures” that reflect the sector’s diversity across “students, institutions and disciplines”.

ADVERTISEMENT

georgia.luckhurst@timeshighereducation.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT