Reducing apprenticeship funding for older people to provide more training for under-25s could harm efforts to reskill the UK’s ageing workforce unless learners are allowed to access student loan funding, university leaders have said.
Although Alan Milburn’s proposals to help get young people not in education, employment or training (Neets) into work has been broadly welcomed by the sector, sector leaders have voiced concerns over his explicit call for the annual English apprenticeship budget be “rebalanced towards youth apprenticeships”
Apprenticeships should “return...to their original purpose – a route for young people into highly skilled work”, explained the former Labour health secretary in his landmark report published on 17 November.
To this effect, government funding for apprenticeships for people aged 25 or over should be reduced 25 per cent, with the savings used to increase funding for young people, urges the report. That could be reduced 50 per cent by 2031-32 “depending on the progress towards expanding youth apprenticeships”, it adds.
With some degree apprenticeships costing £9,000 a year, learners over 25 would be left with a shortfall of almost £10,000 over three years unless employers agree to pay more. In contrast, those under 25 would remain fully funded by both government and employers.
Milburn’s proposal should open the door to a frank discussion about whether degree apprenticeships could be part-funded by learners, said Malcolm Press, president of Universities UK and vice-chancellor of Manchester Metropolitan University.
“We could explore a model in which funding is split between employees and employers, with learners drawing down money from the Student Loan Company,” said Press, noting that two-thirds of degree apprentices are currently over 25.
Removing full funding for older degree apprentices could have “unintended consequences” given many of these learners come from the NHS and other key public sector industries, continued Press.
“These people make a massive contribution to the public sector so removing funding could negatively impact training in places like the NHS,” he said.
The policy recommendation comes as universities have invested heavily in increasing their course offerings for older learners ahead of the introduction of the lifelong learning entitlement (LLE) in January, when students in England will be able to claim loan funding for designated short courses. Institutions have spent years establishing degree apprenticeship courses, although funding for master’s level courses for learners aged 22 or over was withdrawn in January.
“The danger of recognising only one area of national need is that you take your eye off the ball in terms of other areas, namely the growing need to reskill our workforce in an age of significant social and technology disruption,” said David Phoenix, vice-chancellor of the Open University.
“Nine out of 10 nursing apprenticeships at the OU are over 25, which rises to 97 per cent of apprenticeships in social work,” explained Phoenix, who said these qualifications were vital in helping mature students win promotions or move into leadership roles.
“Refocusing on one thing could have unintended consequences. We should be thinking more about how our educational offers work as a system,” said Phoenix, who added that the overwhelming focus on apprenticeships for young people – including degree apprenticeships – ignored alternative qualifications that could be easier to deliver at scale.
“Degree apprenticeships have been a great innovation and increased the contribution from employers but it’s a high-cost, highly regulated model and there are more efficient and effective alternatives if you wanted to address the lack of level 3 to 5 qualifications,” said Phoenix.
Focusing on apprenticeships for under-25 raised the question of whether employers – who pay the apprenticeship levy – would be willing to invest significantly in this cohort without new incentives, said Phoenix. “How will employers respond in the short-term to these changes? If some employers are not able to recruit the people they need we might not see a massive shift in where [training funds] go,” he said.
Vanessa Wilson, chief executive of University Alliance, which represents professional and technical universities, said she was not surprised by the recommendations given Milburn’s focus on young people but felt they were “short-sighted”.
“We have an upskilling and reskilling crisis – we need better skills in our workforce, full stop. It’s regressive to reduce funding for a system that, in our universities, is placing many people in higher-paid positions across a number of sectors,” said Wilson.
“We’re not talking about executives taking MBAs but people who need to upskill to move through the sector and take leadership roles,” she continued, adding that these promotions created space for entry-level roles that could be taken by younger people, thus helping to address youth unemployment.
“We should focus on resolving the Neet crisis but we risk creating problems elsewhere if we remove funding in this way,” said Wilson.
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to THE’s university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?






