ADVERTISEMENT

Don’t read the Milburn review as an attack on higher education

We must press upon policymakers the evidence that the value of a high-quality university education will only grow in the coming years, says Michael Spence

An acrobat is lifted up beneath a rocket during a performance at a circus. To illustrate that the value of a high-quality university education will only grow in the coming years, providing opportunities for young people in the UK.

Source: Leon Neal/Getty Images

The publication of the Milburn review of young people not in education, employment or training is a fresh spur for serious conversations about opportunities, support and education for young people in the UK. This conversation must proceed with universities, not at our expense.

In particular, it is our responsibility to ensure that the review takes the long view of the skills needs of our economy. We do this by being direct about the problems we face and the solutions we tangibly offer.

Among those is the fact that promising students, even at some prestigious universities, are now told they will need to wait 18 months and apply at least 200 times to find graduate employment. I am proud that nine in 10 UCL graduates are in work within 15 months of graduating. Yet I do not imagine for a second that we are immune to the wider challenges affecting the UK economy. We can and do work closely with employers: 76 per cent of our undergraduates already undertake work-related learning with them. We must and we will find ways to develop this relationship to ensure our students’ smooth transition to working life.

Another challenge is technological disruption, which disrupts assessment and authenticity in the classroom and our approach to knowledge in the world at large. Rising costs, diminishing opportunities and global disruption are also felt acutely in the UK.

The review looks toward the longer term, and we must too. For beyond today’s headlines a rather different problem emerges. The evidence points to two important trends.

ADVERTISEMENT

The first is that there will be more graduate-level jobs in the next decade, and there will be fewer people with the relevant skills to fill them. 

It is also apparent that employers are not just looking for technical skills. Six in 10 cited a need for creative thinkers to harness new technologies, while half explicitly looked to arts and humanities graduates to navigate the complexities of a changing world.

These trends call for action now, just as the immediate challenges of graduate employment do. Universities and the degrees we offer must earn their relevance by anticipating future economic, social and cultural needs, rather than deferring to past practice. How can we respond amid a crisis in funding, trust and outcomes?

For practical steps, I look to the work of colleagues and partners at UCL. Our ExtendED Learning programme provides students with employability and entrepreneurship training, engagement with employers and the chance to develop their own business ideas. The UCL Student Union’s Leaders in Dialogue programme provides students with the opportunity to learn how to discuss challenging issues and navigate complex disagreements – the sort of soft skill that the individualised bubble of AI interaction makes all the more essential. These are just two examples of simple, scalable ideas with a clear impact.

Something the sector must recall in the heated discussion of our changing role is that good-faith critique of our current practice is not slander – and pessimism is not a strategy. The evidence shows that there is enduring value to a high-quality education and that the need for this education will only grow. It is on us to work with policymakers to ensure sight of this future is not lost – while we also work with partners from across the sector, industry and the world at large to address the immediate challenges we all face.

Michael Spence is president and provost of UCL.

Read more about

UK higher education policySkills and apprenticeshipsGraduate employment