University dropouts should receive a qualification that could be transferred to another institution if they complete their first year, Alan Milburn’s report into young people “not in education, employment or training” (NEETs) has recommended.
Criticising the UK’s “fragmented tertiary system”, the former Labour health secretary identifies what he called a “missing middle” of technical skills at levels 4 and 5, noting how only 18 per cent of England-based learners gained a qualification between level 3 (A level or equivalent) and level 6 (bachelor’s degree) compared with 52 per cent of learners graduating with a degree.
Urging the sector to “rebalance provision towards level 4 and 5 skills”, Millburn says the government should “establish annual step-off qualifications with portable credit, so that learners completing each year of higher education receive a recognised award, for example, a level 4 qualification after the first year”.
“This would allow learners to move between providers, return to study later and build recognised learning towards a larger qualification without having to start again,” says Milburn’s long-awaited report, published on 17 November. It also notes that this qualification would “align with commitments in the Skills White Paper to work towards ‘more flexible, modular provision’ for higher level skills”.
The proposal follows repeated calls in past decades to establish a system of transferable or stackable credits in which prior learning at other institutions is formally recognised and accredited, similar to the US system that allows students to use qualifications from community colleges to shorten the time it takes to receive a full honours degree.
Reflecting on the difficulties of different institutions accepting each other’s credits, Milburn states: “There should not be a national curriculum for universities. Institutions should retain freedom over what and how they teach.”
However, “a degree in one institution should meet a standard that can be understood and trusted alongside a degree in another”, says Milburn, who nonetheless advises that “such a change should be tested with the sector before wider implementation”.
To accompany this change Milburn also calls for an “Open University for skills”, which is described as a “national digital Open College through which people can find and accumulate modules from colleges, universities and approved providers, with AI helping them navigate choices”.
This entity would, however, sit over existing institutions, rather than creating a new provider” and would be “part-funded by employers and other private investors”.
Most of Milburn’s recommendations on post-18 education relate, however, to apprenticeships, calling for a “new national ambition” to “double the number of young people achieving an apprenticeship over the next decade so that apprenticeships rival university as a mainstream destination for school leavers”.
“By 2036-37, around 35 per cent of each cohort of young people should have started a high-quality apprenticeship by the age of 25,” the report says, explaining that this would mean increasing annual under-25s enrolments from about 172,000 in 2024-25 to 270,000 by 2036-37, with about 215,000 young people achieving an apprenticeship a year.
According to Ucas figures for 2024-25 some 564,940 learners were accepted on to full-time undergraduate courses from some 750,000 applicants.
That pledge echoes calls by former prime minister Keir Starmer for two-thirds of young people in the UK to attend university or study a technical qualification after leaving school, although no definitive split between the two routes was mentioned.
In his report. Milburn urges universities to “increasingly see degree apprenticeships as part of their core contribution to widening opportunity”, praising its “ability to innovate in how it delivers higher-level skills, including through the growth of degree apprenticeships over the past decade”.
However, the “NEET crisis should help prompt a strategic rethink about the role of HE within the wider tertiary system and how public resources are allocated across competing priorities”, he writes.
The apprenticeship system should be “refocused on providing more opportunities for young people” rather than lifelong learning, with government funding for over-25s apprenticeships to be “reduced by 25 per cent with the savings used to increase funding for young people” and, by 2031-32, that contribution towards over-25s could fall by as much as 50 per cent.
Milburn also recommends a further education applications service similar to Ucas.
Like the “Open University for skills”, this would not require the creation of a new agency but instead of a “single national application system, every strategic authority should establish a simple, Ucas-style local access point through which young people can see the education, training and apprenticeship opportunities available across their area and understand what employment outcomes they achieve”.
“Choosing a technical route should be no harder to navigate than choosing a university,” says the report.
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to THE’s university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?








