Academics feel “silenced” by their universities and say they are often too busy to participate in public debates, according to researchers who have tracked a global “retreat” from “intellectual leadership”.
A study based on interviews with nearly 600 academics across the world has warned that a “culture of fear” developing in academia is stifling engagement.
Published in the journal Higher Education Quarterly, the paper, “The Retreat from Intellectual Leadership: Exploring the professoriate’s reticence to profess”, defines intellectual leadership in three ways: the advance of the disciplinary field; a substantive contribution to scholarship and public debate; and academic mentorship.
It argues that academics’ ability to pursue these goals is under threat because of an increasing focus on productivity within universities, often driven by financial pressures, and “institutional silencing”, which prevents academics from speaking in the public realm.
Despite there being protections for the right to academic freedom, respondents describe a “culture of fear that prevents academics from speaking out” as well as worries about getting “smacks on the wrist” for taking part in public engagement. Respondents say that intellectual leadership is viewed “as a source of profound professional jeopardy, causing them to ‘play it safe’”.
Faculty most commonly experienced the pressure to keep silent in connection with addressing external audiences. One respondent told researchers: “Our university limits our ability to speak publicly on behalf of our institution with regards to issues of public controversy, even if the area is related to the life of our community or in some way related to our academic work.”
The paper holds this up as evidence that “universities suppress the very critical inquiry that is core to academics’ scholarly mission, while simultaneously stage-managing an impression of the campus as a site of open debate”.
Richard Watermeyer, lead author of the paper and professor of education at the University of Bristol, told Times Higher Education that this is a loss for the academic community and beyond, noting that it marks the “disappearance of the academic as a public intellectual”.
“Fundamentally, I think a lot of this chimes with the [suppression] of academic freedoms that we’ve seen all over the world in quite explicit and then more tacit kinds of ways.
“Critical voices are being blunted. And I think there’s a nervousness of people speaking out, speaking truth to power, holding power accountable, and all the standard things that for most people who came into the academic game thought were the underpinnings of what it was to be a scholar,” he said.
Financial conditions and workload pressures were also blamed for stifling intellectual leadership. One respondent says their senior management has been growing “more business oriented, less academically oriented and does not encourage intellectual leadership any more”.
The paper says traditional forms of intellectual leadership – such as research and mentorship – “do not align with efficiency models” that “fail to recognise or reward the contribution”.
Watermeyer – who authored the paper with Bristol colleague Rodolfo Benites as well as Mary Sheridan, of the University of Louisville; Bruce Macfarlane of Durham University; and Richard Bolden of the University of the West of England – added that academics are being “suffocated” by productivity demands, meaning that “finding that space to say critical things is closing down”.
With universities across the world facing funding challenges, and many institutions in the UK embarking on major job cuts programmes, academics are “unintentionally or forcibly having to be a lot more invested in their own self-preservation”, Watermeyer said.
This means being “much more guarded and individualistic in terms of outlook and self-protection”.
“The threads that bind us as a community, I think, are increasingly challenged. The conditions which allow academics to exercise critical conscience and collegiality are eroding,” he said.
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to THE’s university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?








