Returning to in-person exams ‘the worst thing we could do’

Going analogue a poor test of students’ skills, says provost, after regulator flags assessments ‘not fit for purpose’

Published on
November 17, 2026
Last updated
November 17, 2026
Source: Getty/Wirestock

Pushing a return to in-person assessment would be the “worst thing” the sector could do in response to artificial intelligence, according to the provost of a private university.

Kelly Coate, of Richmond American University London, has hit back at guidance issued by regulator the Office for Students (OfS) earlier this month, which sought to preserve “valid and reliable” assessment in the age of AI.

The advice was issued following the publication of a four-month study by the OfS and Advance HE that found AI use to be widespread among students and university employees.

The regulator has not mandated its preferred forms of assessment but has encouraged greater use of in-person testing, presentations and vivas (oral examinations).

ADVERTISEMENT

But Coate, formerly pro vice-chancellor for education and students at the University of Sussex, dismissed the idea that in-person exams are inherently safe from cheating.

“I think the worst thing we could do as a whole-institution approach is [to] go back to in-person exams,” she told a webinar hosted by the Higher Education Policy Institute and learning platform Studiosity.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I was hugely disappointed that the Ofs report referenced in-person exams as a possibly secure method of assessing students. We’ve been trying for decades to move universities away from in-person exams because they are so completely limited in what they test of students and their abilities.”

Asked whether there was a need for an overarching national framework on the application of AI within education, Sam Illingworth, professor of critical AI literacy at Edinburgh Napier University, also appeared to criticise the OfS’ recent contribution to the debate.

“What I don’t want to see is lip service from a government agency putting something through without thinking about all of the actors that are involved,” he said.

“If we’re putting together a framework that should be adaptable and adoptable by an individual institution, it needs to include the voice of educators, it needs to include the voice of trade unions, it needs to include the voice of administrators but, most importantly of all, it needs to include the voice of students at that initial stage.”

Josh Freeman, strategy manager at the OfS, defended the regulator’s Making AI Work for Students report, saying it was underpinned by conversations with nearly 100 students and 200 teaching staff members.

ADVERTISEMENT

He also defended its broader approach to exams, saying it “is not our place to tell institutions exactly what they should do, but rather to set the framework within which higher education institutions operate”, adding: “We hope that this has been a helpful intervention.”

He said the OfS was “seeing some things” that “give [it] concern”, including “weakening assessment”.

“Many assessments used in the sector just aren’t fit for purpose,” he claimed. “If we have a model that is a remote take-home essay and then we try and verify whether AI was used through an AI detector, we know that that's not reliable because we know that AI can complete that essay to a high standard in ways that aren’t detectable.”

ADVERTISEMENT

Freeman argued there was an “important equality of opportunity implication here”, when it comes to some students benefiting from more expensive, paid-for AI services – and potentially better grades as a result.

Designing assessments that “effectively measure students’ knowledge”, said Freeman, would involve “much greater use of AI-free assessments than previously”.

“This is difficult, we recognise that, and it is hard to make these accessible,” he added. “They are resource-intensive as well.

“But it is, we think, necessary to ensure the credibility and the effectiveness of assessments.”

ADVERTISEMENT

georgia.luckhurst@timeshighereducation.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Reader's comments (1)

new
The worst thing we can do is to not bring back in person exams. AI is too clever and leads to lots of cheating by students, the students that cheat can get higher marks than those that do not. So Kelly Coates has no clue what she is speaking about. In person exams properly test students and make them work to succeed and sort out the better and weaker students. For once I agree with the OfS.

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT