Burnham’s regional innovation push ‘needs clearer priorities’

Funders, universities and local leaders often disagree about what devolved research spending can achieve, report warns

Published on
November 17, 2026
Last updated
November 17, 2026
Source: Getty Images/alex_west

Different understandings of innovation among national funders, universities and local leaders could undermine the government’s regional growth push, a report has warned.

The Local Policy Innovation Partnership (LPIP) Hub at the City-REDI University of Birmingham institute has urged the government to establish clearer priorities to ensure that the £1 billion in funding it is diverting over the next four years supports local needs with pioneering research.

As prime minister, Andy Burnham has pledged to use UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) money to develop nationally coordinated regional clusters, but he has not revealed much further detail.

A report from the LPIP Hub report on 17 November says the project is threatened by “conceptual slippage across institutional contexts”, with interpretations of innovation shifting depending on the objectives of funders, universities and local leaders.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Differences over what constitutes innovation can have far-reaching ramifications for regional growth”, said Nicola Headlam, the co-author of the report and a place fellow at LPIP Hub.

“For a research funder, innovation might be a scientific breakthrough or a new technology reaching the market. For a local leader, it could be helping existing businesses become more productive and create jobs.

ADVERTISEMENT

“Both are important, but when funding decisions favour one interpretation over another, places without established research strengths risk missing out on investment that could make a real difference to their economies.”

The report says combined authorities tend to view innovation through an economic development lens, whereas UKRI and many universities view it through an industrial innovation lens.

“A major reason for current friction is that many funding systems still privilege novelty, R&D, and commercialisation, while weaker regions often need support for diffusion, adoption, capability-building, and translational infrastructure,” the report says.

Therefore, policy should be “realistic” and allow regions to build their own portfolios based on where they have “genuine strengths” and to seek translational and commercialisation support where necessary.

ADVERTISEMENT

The government should also establish “diffusion and adoption programmes where the bigger issue is weak business capability or thin innovation ecosystems”, the report says.

The result of the current “slippage” is “a deeper mismatch over what counts as innovation, what activity is fundable, and what successful outcomes look like”, the report says. It adds that the findings, which are based on a comparative analysis of five different actors including UKRI, universities and combined authorities, help to explain “recurrent dissatisfaction in bidding and assessment processes”.

Bec Riley, director of the LPIP Hub and co-author of the report, said: “Working across national and regional policy, we have repeatedly seen people talking at cross purposes about what innovation schemes should achieve. We wrote this review in response to that disconnect, especially given the vast sums of public money at stake.”

For Riley and Headlam, the strongest government package would be a broader policy mix including explicit support for diffusion and adoption, and investment in subnational policy capability.

ADVERTISEMENT

frances.jones@timeshighereducation.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT