University staff back Burnham over Starmer but Greens hold allure

New UK prime minister urged to adopt more progressive stance, including lifting ‘harmful’ student visa restrictions

Published on
July 20, 2026
Last updated
July 20, 2026
 Polling station signs in UK
Source: Getty Images/Alphotographic

University workers have more faith in new UK prime minister Andy Burnham than in his predecessor Keir Starmer, while the majority believe education secretary Bridget Phillipson is “performing badly”, according to a poll.

The former Manchester mayor is set to become prime minister on 20 July and is expected to appoint a new Cabinet, including likely shaking up the team in charge of education as universities continue to face financial challenges, resulting in mass layoffs.

New polling of about 7,000 University and College Union (UCU) members found that more than four in 10 (42 per cent) are more likely to support the Labour Party with Burnham as prime minister.

The figures suggest members had lost faith in Starmer, with under a third (29 per cent) saying they would have voted for the former prime minister if an election had been held in the past few weeks, despite almost half (45 per cent) of respondents having voted for the party in the 2024 general election.

ADVERTISEMENT

While university staff may feel relatively positive about the new prime minister, Burnham is widely expected to prioritise supporting alternative options to university for young people, rather than saving the higher education sector.

In a speech in June, he pledged to end the “days of a school system configured entirely around the university route”.

ADVERTISEMENT

Burnham’s Cabinet changes are expected to be wide-ranging after Starmer attempted to introduce some continuity into departments following years of upheaval. Bridget Phillipson and Jacqui Smith have overseen higher education for two years but are now seen as at risk of being moved on and replaced by figures closer to Burnham.

The poll, carried out at the end of June, found that 64 per cent of respondents believed education secretary Bridget Phillipson was “performing badly”.

UCU general secretary Jo Grady said the data suggest Burnham “has the potential to revive Labour”.

“Labour did so badly in May’s [local council] elections because it haemorrhaged voters to the Greens,” she said.

ADVERTISEMENT

The polling found almost twice as many respondents thought the Green Party (29 per cent) better reflected their views on education than Labour (15 per cent).

“Our members, working in colleges and universities across the UK, are representative of the coalition of voters Burnham needs to build,” Grady continued.

“Labour’s current strategy of moving to the right on immigration, including attacking higher education by restricting international staff and student recruitment in a bid to attract Reform voters, failed dramatically in May. Burnham must now take a more progressive stance if he wants to build a coalition of voters that will enable him to win a general election.”

While Burnham has yet to announce his policy plans, there are doubts about how progressive he will be compared with the previous administration.

ADVERTISEMENT

Burnham is reportedly considering appointing current home secretary Shabana Mahmood as chancellor.

During her time at the Home Office, Mahmood oversaw increasingly restrictive visa policies related to universities, including implementing a “visa brake” for international students from four countries and the introduction of stricter compliance rules that have made it riskier to recruit overseas students.

ADVERTISEMENT

‘Higher education is one of the few sectors in which the UK remains a world leader and, when supported properly, has cascading economic benefits, both regionally and nationally,” Grady said. “The incoming prime minister must lift the economically harmful visa restrictions and invest in universities.”

helen.packer@timeshighereducation.com

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Reader's comments (1)

new
Bizarre polling. The Prime Minister of the UK is responsible for UK Research Councils, visas for overseas students, employment laws and the overall economic and fiscal framework and performance of the UK state. It's therefore perfectly legitimate to ask UCU members across the UK state what they think of the PM's performance. However, the UK government's Education Secretary, Bridget Phillipson, is ONLY responsible for Education in ENGLAND - education including Schools, Further Education, Higher Education teaching funding, quality research and governance is entirely a devolved matter. So why ask UCU members in Scottish, Welsh and NI institutions what they think of someone who has absolutely nothing to do with their institution and about whom they may well know very little other than what they read in the press? What next? Ask UCU members in Welsh institutions what they think of the performance of Mairi McAllan (the SNP Scottish Cabinet Secretary for Education)? Ask UCU members in English institutions what they think of the performance of Paul Givan (the DUP Northern Ireland Executive's Minister for Education)? Ask UCU members in Northern Ireland institutions what they think of the performance of Philippe Baptiste (the non-party French government minister for higher education, research and ... er space)? It's a shame, because you can actually interpret what you like about Phillipson from such a nonsense survey sample, whereas Phillipson deserves to be held to account for those in England working for English institutions. Michael Picken, Glasgow

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT