How teachers can learn to lead

Many teachers make the leap into management thinking it is a natural next step. They have mastered classrooms, guided hundreds of students and earned the respect of peers. Yet, once in charge of colleagues, they find themselves frustrated and out of their depth. Meetings stall. Staff disengage. Control slips away.

It is not because they are incapable; it is because the job has changed. Teaching and managing draw on different moral centres: one thrives on control, the other on trust. Moving from one to the other requires rewiring how you see people, authority and success.

You are no longer the expert

In a classroom, your expertise defines the space. You lead through knowledge. Students rely on your direction. The relationship is vertical. In management, you are now surrounded by adults with their own competencies, motivations and blind spots. The best managers do not prove they know more; they prove they listen better.

Stop trying to be the smartest person in the room. Be the one who clears obstacles so others can excel. Ask “What do you need from me to move forward?” instead of saying “Here’s what you should do.” Leadership is not the performance of authority; it is the quiet coordination of other people’s abilities.

Let go of the ‘teacher voice’

Teachers are trained to project confidence and control. That tone holds a classroom together. 

You cannot manage professionals with the same cadence you use to guide students. Replace correction with curiosity. When someone misses a deadline, skip the lecture. Try “Tell me what happened” or “What might help next time?” The tone shift changes everything; it moves the conversation from compliance to collaboration.

Authority in education is positional. Authority in management is relational. It is earned by consistency, honesty and fairness, not by asserting expertise.

• Spotlight guide: Is your academic career cleared for take off?
• How to develop a promotion strategy for success
• How to become a dean

Build systems, not surveillance

Many teachers-turned-managers default to micromanagement. It feels responsible, even caring, to be involved in every detail. But hovering creates dependence, not excellence.

Good management is structural, not supervisory. When something fails, look for the system flaw before blaming people. Is the process clear? Is communication consistent? Are expectations visible and shared?

A well-built system allows autonomy without chaos. It is like a good curriculum: clear objectives, flexible paths and predictable evaluation. Once the structure works, step back. The goal is to make your presence unnecessary in daily operations.

Listen like a coach

In teaching, silence often signals confusion. In leadership, it often signals reflection. Learn to hold space without rushing to fill it.

When staff come to you with problems, resist the urge to give solutions. Ask guiding questions. Let them articulate what is wrong and propose next steps. Most people know what needs to happen; they just need confidence and clarity.

Coaching is not passive. It is disciplined listening combined with gentle steering. It tells people, “I trust your judgement.” It turns reluctant compliance into self-driven responsibility.

Address conflict early and calmly

Teachers spend years managing behaviour indirectly. In management, avoidance becomes costly. 

When someone underperforms or acts out, address it quickly and privately. Stick to facts; “I noticed reports are consistently late” works better than “You’re unreliable.” Then explore reasons and consequences. Most employees respond well to directness when it is respectful and consistent.

A manager’s calm during conflict becomes the team’s emotional baseline. Set that tone. Clarity and fairness are stronger than charisma.

Learn the discipline of reflection

Good teachers reflect instinctively after a lesson: on what worked, what did not and what to change tomorrow. Managers often lose that habit because the feedback loop is slower.

Take 10 minutes each week to ask yourself:

• What decision helped the team this week?
• What created confusion or frustration?
• What did I learn about myself?

Leadership without reflection hardens into ego. Reflection keeps humility alive, and humility keeps learning possible.

Redefine success

Teachers measure success in visible progress: students mastering material, exams passed, classes engaged. Management success is less tangible. You do not always see the impact of your decisions quickly.

Your new metrics are trust, clarity and momentum. Are people coming to you early with problems or hiding them? Do they understand priorities without constant reminders? Does the team keep improving without your direct push? If yes, you are leading well.

You will know you have crossed the bridge from teacher to leader when the system runs smoothly and you feel almost invisible. That invisibility is not failure; it is mastery.

The hardest part of becoming a manager is not learning how to lead; it is letting go of how you used to lead. Teaching rewards control, clarity and performance. Leadership requires trust, uncertainty and restraint. The move from one to the other is less a promotion than a transformation. If you can unlearn the need to be the centre, you can build something much larger than yourself: a team that works because you created the conditions for it to thrive.

That is the quiet art of real leadership: not standing in front of people but standing behind them while they do their best work.

Garth Elzerman is a lecturer at Xi’an Jiaotong-Liverpool University, China. 

If you would like advice and insight from academics and university staff delivered direct to your inbox each week, sign up for the Campus newsletter.