Full association to the European Union’s next research programme will cost the UK billions more than expected, a new analysis has found.
The European Union (EU) is planning to almost double the budget for the Horizon Europe successor, known as FP10, to €175 billion (£145 billion) with universities pushing for it to reach €200 billion.
But the UK, which has not yet committed to continued association, has only budgeted £2.2 billion a year to participate, roughly the same that it spends on the current programme.
It means Westminster may have to find more than £1 billion a year in extra funding if it wants to continue its membership in the world’s largest research funding programme.
The analysis by Science Works found the projected £7.7 billion shortfall over the life of the programme could rise to £16.5 billion in the “worst case scenario”, with the money likely having to come from other research funding pots.
The thinktank released its findings on the eve of UK-EU reset talks that will discuss how to forge a closer relationship between the two, six years on from Brexit.
Universities have been pushing for the UK to gain “day one” access to FP10 after a prolonged absence from the research programme earlier in the decade.
Previous attempts to fund the Horizon bill through the research and development budget have been met with fierce opposition but the prospect of the UK coming out of Horizon altogether will be equally unpalatable for universities.
But Science Works said the UK should reconsider whether full association should be the goal, given the most likely scenario is a gap of £1.2 billion in 2029-30, rising to £1.5 billion by 2034-35.
This, the organisation highlighted, was equivalent to three times the budget of the Advanced Research and Invention Agency (ARIA), which funds high-risk breakthrough science.
It is also more than half of all quality-related research (QR) funding, the core block grant that supports university research.
The Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade – which now oversees the research budget following the demise of the Department for Science, Innovation and Technology – would have to cut its programmes by more than 10 per cent to cover the bill, Science Works said, before inflation and any cuts to pay for higher defence spending are taken into account.
Cuts to QR could be higher – potentially up to 83 per cent – if the UK waits to fund the grants at the point it is invoiced. “This would hit already-stretched universities hard, forcing some to shutter research facilities or default entirely. If the UK is to fully associate to FP10, it should decide early how to find the funding,” said a statement from Science Works announcing the findings.
Researchers said instead the government should aim to associate only to FP10’s Excellent Science pillar, the area where the UK has historically performed the best.
“Doing so would be £2.4 billion a year cheaper than full association, avoiding the need for cuts and freeing around £1.1 billion annually for investment in British priorities.”
If the UK decides to go for full association, it should negotiate a higher clawback if its researchers underperform, Science Works said. Currently the UK is refunded when grants underperform by 16 per cent. But Switzerland, another associated country, has a trigger point of 8 per cent.
Science Works also warned universities and research organisations against joining calls for a bigger FP10 budget, warning that a Treasury bailout that would maintain funding for other research programmes at their current level was far from guaranteed.
“The European Union is on a mission to supersize their next research programme, and British scientific institutions are determined that the UK joins in,” said Ben Johnson, co-director of Science Works and former senior UK government adviser on science and R&D.
“But a much larger programme comes with a far higher UK entry fee – many billions of pounds more than current budgets allow. Government needs a clear plan for either finding the extra money or rethinking the terms of our involvement. Otherwise, we could face a nightmare scenario where we are forced to endure devastating cuts to UK universities and facilities that would permanently scar British science.”
Register to continue
Why register?
- Registration is free and only takes a moment
- Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
- Sign up for our newsletter
Subscribe
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to THE’s university and college rankings analysis
Already registered or a current subscriber?








