Fractional shifts produce sweet sound of spheres

Music and Mathematics
May 14, 2004

The close association between music and mathematics can be dated back at least to the time of Pythagoras. He, or his followers, noticed that when the string of a musical instrument is stopped at exactly half its length, the resulting note sounds sweet (consonant) when played at the same time as the original. Similarly, when it is stopped at other simple fractions, the resulting harmonies are pleasing. In this way, it is possible to generate all the notes of a major scale, and eventually the sharps and flats as well. This mathematical theory gives a method for tuning musical instruments with a keyboard or with fixed frets.

But it is not the only way to determine the pitch of the notes, and it suffers from a grave defect: it permits the instrument to be played only in the key that it was tuned for. In particular, the sharp of a note is very slightly different from the flat of the note above it. Many mathematicians have investigated the phenomenon, including Plato, Euclid, Johannes Kepler, Marin Mersenne, Galileo's father, Vincenzo, and Isaac Newton. The solution eventually adopted is called equal temperament; it has a fixed ratio between the successive semitones of the 12-semitone chromatic scale. To preserve the exactitude of an octave interval, the ratio has to be the 12th root of 2, an irrational number that would have been difficult for Pythagoreans to accept. It so happens that this gives very good approximations to the original Pythagorean harmonies, and the human ear adjusts well to the slight inaccuracies. Fifty-three notes in the octave would be even more accurate; such an instrument was built in 1876 by Bosanquet, but the idea never caught on.

This is a summary of the story well told by Neil Bibby in the first section of the book. Ian Stewart takes it further in his fascinating contribution, describing a geometrical construction for placing the frets of a guitar that was invented in 1743 by a Swedish craftsman, Daniel Straehle. He was not a mathematician, and when his calculations were checked by Jacob Faggot, one of the founding members of the Swedish Academy, they were found to be in error. But not so: the mistake was actually Faggot's. Stewart's account also gives a clear exposition of the underlying geometry, including the method of neusis that was excluded from the classical geometry of constructions by ruler and compass.

The mathematical cosmology of Kepler presents musical harmony as a factor in explaining the structure of the universe; an idea that persists in the imaginative poetic fallacy of the music of the spheres. Kepler's views and their development by his successors is the subject of a densely written survey by J. V. Field.

Musical sounds and their appreciation by the human ear are a fruitful field for experimental research. The obvious modern approach is to look directly at the musical wave-form as recorded by an oscilloscope; however, this is not readily distinguishable from arbitrary noise and conveys no insight into the meaning and interpretation of the sound. The essay by Charles Taylor on the science of musical sound concentrates on the ways in which different instruments create notes of different timbre by means of different overtones, and on the ways in which the ear perceives the effects of a chord. This latter topic is further developed in the essay by David Taylor on Hermann Helmholtz's experiments with combinational tones and consonances. For example, why does the ear tolerate the inaccuracies of the well-tempered scale while being very sensitive to the exact octave? And why do many people hear additional combinational tones when two sirens are played at different pitches?

The most direct application of mathematics to music is in the analysis of musical compositions, and occasionally also in their construction. A good example is that of bell-ringing. The rules are simple: in each round, all the bells must be rung in some order, and between rounds only two bells may change places (ringing the changes). The objective is to devise ways of ringing all possible rounds exactly once without repetition. For seven bells there are 5,040 different orders - a full peal takes three hours.

English bell-ringers solved the problem of playing all the variations 200 years ago; but it was not until 100 years ago that the problem was analysed in full using the mathematical techniques of group theory. A good introduction (but without too much theory) is given by Dermot Roaf and Arthur White.

Wilfred Hodges contributes an interesting analytical essay entitled "The geometry of music", on the musical use of metaphor, inversions, transpositions, dilations, reflections, rotations and mirror images. It is illustrated by short musical scores from composers as varied as Mozart, Elgar, Bartok, Hindemith and Rimsky-Korsakov.

Modern composers have made explicit use of mathematical constructions to determine the structure of their compositions, and sometimes even to generate note sequences. Jonathan Cross in his chapter on "Composing with numbers" gives examples from Schoenberg, Berg, Webern, Boulez, Maxwell Davies and Xenakis. Some of these examples seem to owe more to numerology than to mathematics, but the claim is made that musical qualities always take precedence over blind application of a formula. Those with a good appreciation for modern music can judge for themselves.

The book ends with contributions by modern composers Carlton Gamer and Robert Sherlaw Johnson. The first gives an example of the use of finite projective planes and their duals to generate sequences in which every interval between two notes of the sequence (not necessarily adjacent) occurs exactly once. The second uses fractal formulae to generate notes and selects the parameters of the formulae to achieve the desired musical effects. The composition is to be played on an eight-channel Midi synthesiser. Fragments of the scores are displayed.

It is generally believed that there is a correlation between professional engagement in music and an amateur interest in mathematics, and vice versa.

This book should appeal equally to both communities, and it will also appeal to those interested in the history of science. Although it is expensively produced, with many black-and-white reproductions of old woodcuts and modern photographs, a few colour illustrations would have made the book more attractive. But an even more welcome addition, especially given the price, would have been the inclusion of a CD containing illustrative examples of the music.

Sir Tony Hoare is senior researcher, Microsoft Research.

Music and Mathematics: From Pythagoras to Fractals

Editor - John Fauvel, Raymond Flood and Robin Wilson
Publisher - Oxford University Press
Pages - 189
Price - £39.50
ISBN - 0 19 851187 6

You've reached your article limit.

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Most Commented

James Fryer illustration (27 July 2017)

It is not Luddism to be cautious about destroying an academic publishing industry that has served us well, says Marilyn Deegan

Jeffrey Beall, associate professor and librarian at the University of Colorado Denver

Creator of controversial predatory journals blacklist says some peers are failing to warn of dangers of disreputable publishers

Hand squeezing stress ball
Working 55 hours per week, the loss of research periods, slashed pensions, increased bureaucracy, tiny budgets and declining standards have finally forced Michael Edwards out
Kayaker and jet skiiers

Nazima Kadir’s social circle reveals a range of alternative careers for would-be scholars, and often with better rewards than academia

hole in ground

‘Drastic action’ required to fix multibillion-pound shortfall in Universities Superannuation Scheme, expert warns