Tory conference: 'Many universities aren't teaching anybody anything’

Claim rejected by UUK chief executive who defends breadth of university sector

September 30, 2014

Many non-Oxbridge universities are “not teaching anybody anything” and there is “dangerous complacency” about the problem, according to a panellist at a fringe meeting at the Conservative Party Conference.

Jenni Russell, a commentator who writes for The Times, Sunday Times and London Evening Standard, told the meeting in Birmingham on 29 September that she had had conversations with business figures “about the inadequacy of British graduates”.

But her views were sharply contradicted by Nicola Dandridge, the Universities UK chief executive, at the event, titled ‘Making the UK the HQ for global talent’, which was hosted by Tory modernising group Bright Blue, UUK and London First.

Ms Russell told the meeting she had spoken with “someone who is now at Credit Suisse and who said to me, ‘we can no longer recruit English graduates, they are just not comparable to the international talent’”.

English graduates have “never been anywhere and can’t speak any other languages and don’t have a sense of the cultures of the rest of the world”, the banker had told her, adding: “Frankly we have a kind of protected area in the bank where we take in English graduates, who just have to deal with some of the English accounts. It’s almost like you’re the disabled in the corner.”

She claimed that part of the problem for the UK was that “a lot of universities are not actually teaching anybody anything very much. The workload [for students] is minimal because academics are being rated on their research output and their articles and their citations, and not in the least on what they are doing for their students.”

Ms Russell said it was “not at all unusual” in arts subjects to have student workload of two essays a term. “That compares with Oxbridge where terms are shorter and the standard is an essay a week, which is eight essays a term,” she added.

Pam Tatlow, the chief executive of Million+, addressing Ms Russell from the audience, said that “the next time you see Credit Suisse you ask them to recruit from some modern universities where actually you get students who are perhaps second generation [the children of immigrants to the UK] and can speak more than one language”.

Ms Dandridge, another member of the panel, said: “There’s so much evidence relating to the quality of UK universities that Jenni didn’t touch on: in terms of graduate employability, [there are] huge benefits from going to university to salary outcomes…To measure quality where your sole terms of reference are Oxbridge and the number of essays that you produce each year really misses the point about the richness of our university sector, where universities are doing all sorts of different things.”

Ms Dandridge added that the success of students on courses co-funded by employers where students spend part of their time in work, for example, “can’t be measured in the same way as if you were writing essays at Oxford”.

Ms Russell responded that such views were “dangerously complacent”.

She said: “There has been a real change in the way universities operate. Twenty or 30 years ago it was a principle that if you were in a new university you delivered an education that was explicitly as taxing as those in the old universities.”

She added: “People of my generation who went to universities which were not Oxbridge had masses of teaching… that is just not the case anymore and it’s been an explicit decision.”

john.morgan@tesglobal.com

You've reached your article limit

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 6 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

Reader's comments (4)

Yes, because PPE at Oxford has been SUCH a boon, hasn't it?
Perhaps some universities and their Arts faculties need reform, and refocusing towards degree courses accredited by the Professional bodies. Many modern universities already offer such useful opportunities.
Sadly, the problem for Ms Russell appears to be her own ignorance and ill-informed snobbery. You have to ask yourself, what type of graduates are Credit Suisse employing to operate in a customer facing role? Most likely, such graduates that are not using the subject matter of their degrees at all, i.e. Ms Russell's contact was actually saying that a degree in English from say ..Manchester, does not provide Credit Suisse with a well connected, blazer-wearing , multi-lingual escapee of the Bullingdon club, fresh from a gap year funded by 'daddy'. I am sure that is correct. However, many more discerning (and perhaps less parasitic) employers do not simply treat the UK University system as some sort of state funded finishing school. My son is about to start an Engineering degree at Imperial College (Currently ranked 2nd in the world in the 2014-15 QS World University Rankings). In year 4 he will be working in Europe or the USA on his Masters degree. When he finishes, he will doubtless use his skills directly in his chosen career, where the average starting salary for a graduate is >30K and jobs are plentiful. Ms Russell criticises broadly, while her criticism actually appears ill-defined and underpinned by snobbery and ignorance. No
Yes shock horror. A journalist whose career depends on serving up right wing platitudes to comfortable, serves up another set, based on a banker she met. It would be funny, if this was not how public debate in this country was carried on. Where to start: obsession with Oxbridge, language skills are universally bad (no better at Oxbridge) and as usual the breath taking ignorance of the fact that Universities teach science, medicine, vocational degrees (eg nursing, pharmacy, optometry, social work, teaching), engineering not just Arts. Writing an essay a week did nothing to teach Ms Russell to avoid a sloppy and poorly researched presentation.

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Most Commented

question marks PhD study

Selecting the right doctorate is crucial for success. Robert MacIntosh and Kevin O'Gorman share top 10 tips on how to pick a PhD

Pencil lying on open diary

Requesting a log of daily activity means that trust between the institution and the scholar has broken down, says Toby Miller

India, UK, flag

Sir Keith Burnett reflects on what he learned about international students while in India with the UK prime minister

Application for graduate job
Universities producing the most employable graduates have been ranked by companies around the world in the Global University Employability Ranking 2016
Construction workers erecting barriers

Directly linking non-EU recruitment to award levels in teaching assessment has also been under consideration, sources suggest