PhD from low-ranking university ‘can hold back career’

Deluge of submitted papers leads journals to fall back on alma mater prestige, research suggests

September 7, 2015
Judges, Vancouver Winter Olympics, Whistler, Canada
Source: Getty
Sliding scale: economists’ CVs could determine how their research is viewed

What happens when a journal reviewer gets out of bed on the wrong side? In a foul mood, they might reject a perfectly good paper over breakfast – leaving the author unpublished, purely due to bad luck.

In economic language, this arbitrary interference in the selection process is called “noise”, and according to a recently presented paper, it may lead to the rejection of papers simply because their authors are from less prestigious universities.

Early career economists with a PhD from an institution that is not among the world’s top 100 universities for the discipline are one-third as likely to be published in one of the top five economics journals as those with a more prestigious alma mater, two scholars have found.

Sergey Popov, a lecturer at Queen’s University Belfast, and Sascha Baghestanian, a junior professor in economics at Goethe University Frankfurt, modelled the impact of rising submission and rejection rates in journals of economics.  

With more submitted articles to handle, reviewers have less time to assess their quality, said Dr Popov.

“The other thing [journals] do is employ less capable referees. This lowers the precision [of assessment],” he added.

A less precise reviewing process increases the influence of “noise” in the process – for example the reviewer’s mood, personal preferences with respect to writing style or the particular topic of the paper – that is not related to genuine scholarly quality, said Dr Popov.

When the quality of the paper matters less, weaker authors have more chance of being published through sheer luck and top scholars have to work harder to ensure their talent shines through, argues “On publication, refereeing, and working hard”, presented last month at the European Economic Association’s annual congress in Mannheim.

With more noise in the process, journals will be more likely to judge submissions using the reputation of the author’s university as a proxy for quality, with troubling consequences for early career researchers at lower-ranked institutions.

This tallies with previous findings by the same authors published last year. Looking at the careers of 100 top economists, they found that academics’ PhD-granting university and the institution where they landed their first job had a big impact on early career success.

If a researcher who graduated from a university ranked in the world’s top 10 for the discipline has a 30 per cent chance of being published in a prestigious journal, one with an alma mater outside the top 100 only has a one in 10 chance, found “Alma mat(t)er(s): determinants of early career success in economics”.

“Economists from lower-ranked alma maters tend to be discounted significantly across all fields, suggesting a potential inefficiency in the dissemination process of scientific thought,” it warned.

While the authors have so far looked only at publishing in economics, Dr Popov said that the findings could apply to any field where competition to be published was increasing.

david.matthews@tesglobal.com

You've reached your article limit

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 6 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

Related universities

POSTSCRIPT:

Print headline: Why your alma definitely matters

Reader's comments (1)

During the refereeing process the referee shouldn't know anything at all about the writer or writers. She or he should make a judgement purely on the basis of the paper itself.

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Most Commented

question marks PhD study

Selecting the right doctorate is crucial for success. Robert MacIntosh and Kevin O'Gorman share top 10 tips on how to pick a PhD

Pencil lying on open diary

Requesting a log of daily activity means that trust between the institution and the scholar has broken down, says Toby Miller

India, UK, flag

Sir Keith Burnett reflects on what he learned about international students while in India with the UK prime minister

Application for graduate job
Universities producing the most employable graduates have been ranked by companies around the world in the Global University Employability Ranking 2016
Construction workers erecting barriers

Directly linking non-EU recruitment to award levels in teaching assessment has also been under consideration, sources suggest