Peer-to-peer criticism

September 27, 2012

In "Peer pressure" (Opinions, 13 September), Stephen Mumford points out some of the flaws of the peer review system used by most academic journals and argues for greater transparency in the process. In this respect he is certainly correct.

However, Mumford is surely incorrect when he states that "reviewers are...largely unaccountable...there appears to be little sanction against a sloppy, negative review...and the author has no right of reply". On two occasions, I have challenged editorial decisions based on reviews that were either inaccurate or misleading. In both cases, the editor accepted my arguments, sent the manuscripts out for further review and the papers were subsequently published. These papers have since been well cited, vindicating my stance.

I am not suggesting that authors should routinely dispute negative reviews - during a 20-year career, I have had my fair share that I've not taken up with editors. But if an argument can be made that a review is fundamentally flawed, editors, in my experience, are willing to listen.

Jeff Ollerton, Professor of biodiversity, School of Science and Technology, University of Northampton

You've reached your article limit.

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Featured Jobs

Most Commented

men in office with feet on desk. Vintage

Three-quarters of respondents are dissatisfied with the people running their institutions

A group of flamingos and a Marabou stork

A right-wing philosopher in Texas tells John Gill how a minority of students can shut down debates and intimidate lecturers – and why he backs Trump

A face made of numbers looks over a university campus

From personalising tuition to performance management, the use of data is increasingly driving how institutions operate

students use laptops

Researchers say students who use computers score half a grade lower than those who write notes

Canal houses, Amsterdam, Netherlands

All three of England’s for-profit universities owned in Netherlands