Credit rating complexities

January 12, 2012

Much is made of a possible analogy between the case of Jules Hoffmann and Bruno Lemaitre and that of Selman Waksman and Albert Schatz ("Did Hoffmann take the Nobel for the team?", 22/29 December).

Readers should know that Peter Lawrence's argument that Schatz was unjustly denied the Nobel prize is highly contentious and rests in part on the claims made by Schatz himself in a lifelong campaign for recognition. Waksman, awarded the prize in 1952 for the discovery of streptomycin, managed a large-scale and systematic programme for the isolation and testing of antibacterial agents. The evidence suggests that it is also plausible that the work Schatz did might have been carried out by another student had the work been assigned by Waksman to them.

The issue of the credit in the case is now one of scholarly dispute. The notion of a "moment of discovery" is hardly appropriate for much of modern science, of which Waksman's programme is an early example. Even if there were such a moment, would it show where credit belongs? Should historians seek the name of the ship's boy who shouted "land ahoy!" as the true discoverer of a continent as opposed to the captain who commanded the ship? And should the captain's lack of contribution be shown by the fact that he never visited the crow's nest?

Alexander Bird, University of Bristol

You've reached your article limit.

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Most Commented

James Fryer illustration (27 July 2017)

It is not Luddism to be cautious about destroying an academic publishing industry that has served us well, says Marilyn Deegan

Jeffrey Beall, associate professor and librarian at the University of Colorado Denver

Creator of controversial predatory journals blacklist says some peers are failing to warn of dangers of disreputable publishers

Hand squeezing stress ball
Working 55 hours per week, the loss of research periods, slashed pensions, increased bureaucracy, tiny budgets and declining standards have finally forced Michael Edwards out
Kayaker and jet skiiers

Nazima Kadir’s social circle reveals a range of alternative careers for would-be scholars, and often with better rewards than academia

hole in ground

‘Drastic action’ required to fix multibillion-pound shortfall in Universities Superannuation Scheme, expert warns