Conspiracies of Conspiracies: How Delusions Have Overrun America, by Thomas Milan Konda

Today’s conspiracists see all social phenomena as resulting from dark intrigues – but why, Jane O’Grady wants to know

May 9, 2019
Conspiracy poster
Source: Shutterstock/Getty
Stigmatised: hatred inspires most conspiracy theories, which, among other things, have led to a growth in antisemitism

The term “conspiracy theory” was first used in a pejorative sense by the philosopher Karl Popper. Detecting dark plots behind untoward events, he said, was a substitute for religion, a secular attempt to read meaning, purpose and connections into a frighteningly indifferent universe. But, by the same token, theism is also a “conspiracy theory”, and the phrase itself is question-begging: it can be used as a gagging label by the establishment – and sometimes, as with Watergate, a “conspiracy” really is a conspiracy.

Thomas Milan Konda, emeritus professor of political science at SUNY Plattsburgh, mentions such problems only perfunctorily. His main concern is with paradigm conspiracy theories, and what he considers their 21st-century permutation – conspiracism: the outlook that explains all social phenomena as resulting from conspiracies, which are seen as not only ubiquitous but also overarchingly connected. In various combinations, the Knights Templar, the Illuminati (an 18th-century religious sect), Jews, Freemasons, Catholics, Communists and proliferating others are part of a plot to take over the world.

Unoriginally, Konda diagnoses conspiracists as paranoid and narcissistic, powered by a sense of powerlessness. While vaunting distrust of authority, and disdain for the “sheeple” so complacently hoodwinked by it, they themselves, he says, tend to be authoritarian and fearful of non-conforming otherness. For them, reality is a Manichaean narrative of good (us) versus evil (them). It is hatred, rather than the purported thirst for truth, that inspires conspiracists; hence their rampant inconsistencies. The Jews, apparently, are both Bolsheviks and bankers – although they sometimes turn out not to be Jewish. According to the Khazarists and British Israelites, the Jews among us are descendants of Turkish Khazars or Mongols; the true Jews, with properly biblical lineage, are white Northern Europeans. Differences of narrative and label, of course, prove irrelevant: the very same people are stigmatised.

Conspiracy theories may take the form of “denialism”, as with global warming. Always (Konda echoes Popper) they are intransigently unfalsifiable. Any atrocity with an apparently obvious explanation (Pearl Harbor, 9/11) has to be a “false flag” perpetrated by its ostensible victims. “That’s what they want you to think” is the mantra of all conspiracy theorists. But if “they” are so cunning, why do they invariably leave quite unnecessary clues and codes to their inscrutable plots? To tease us, the cognoscenti, say conspiracists.

Offbeat beliefs that elude scientific or government attention (the Loch Ness monster, the yeti) never quite hatch into conspiracy theories. Ironically, though, Konda describes how some UFOs were in fact genuine sightings of secret aircraft; subsequent cover-ups by the CIA only exacerbated the myth-making, soon leading to alien encounters and the involvement of the Illuminati.

Just as clerics invoke God’s mysterious ways whenever convenient, yet are somehow privy to the intricate and arbitrary rules of conduct He requires, so conspiracists unearth impenetrable secrets for which they produce the most detailed, convoluted solutions. Their vaunted lack of credulity in one area is matched by an overabundance of credulousness in another. Konda doesn’t analyse this lopsidedness or consider why, where the standard theist discerns hidden benevolence in the world, the conspiracist decries malignity. Conspiracies of Conspiracies is short on philosophical and psychological analysis; overly academic and detailed. I felt the conspiracy theorist’s craving for an overarching structure and message, for clues in a plethora of detail and for something more startlingly new.

Jane O’Grady is a co-founder of the London School of Philosophy and taught philosophy of psychology at City, University of London. She is the author of Enlightenment Philosophy in a Nutshell: The Complete Guide to the Great Revolutionary Philosophers, including René Descartes, Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Immanuel Kant, and David Hume (2019).


Conspiracies of Conspiracies: How Delusions Have Overrun America
By Thomas Milan Konda
University of Chicago Press, 456pp, £23.00
ISBN 9780226585765
Published 29 March 2019

Please login or register to read this article.

Register to continue

Get a month's unlimited access to THE content online. Just register and complete your career summary.

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

POSTSCRIPT:

Print headline: We’re all plotters’ playthings now

Reader's comments (2)

Hello everyone I am Mr Smith Benson from USA, I am giving a testimony on how I joined the illuminati brotherhood, I was trying to join this organization for so many years now,I was scammed by fake agent in south Africa and Nigeria,I was down,I could not feed my self and my family anymore and I tried to make money by all miss but all avail, I was afraid to contact any Illuminati agent because they have eat my money. One day I across a post of someone giving a testimony, thanking a man called Paul mark of being helping him to join the illuminati brotherhood, then I look at the man email and the phone number that was written there, it was a Nigeria number I was afraid to contact him because a Nigeria agent eat my $5,000 and go away with the money then I was very tired, confused and I decided to contact the person that was given the testimony and i called him and I communicated with him on phone calls before he started telling me his own story about when he wanted to join, he told me everything to do, then I made up my mind and called the agent called Paul mark and he told me everything to do, and I was initiated, surprisingly I was given my benefit of being a new member of the great illuminati brotherhood I was so happy,For those of you trying to join this organization this is your opportunity for you to join CONTACT MR PAUL MARK call (+2348163028633 or WhatsApp him +2348163028633 or email: illuminatiworldoffamous@gmail.com
Welcome to illuminati brotherhood where you can become rich famous and popular and your life story we be change totally. my name is Harrison I am here to share my testimony on how I join the great brotherhood Illuminati and my life story was change immediately . I was very poor no job and I has no money to even feed and take care of my family I was confuse in life I don’t know what to do I try all my possible best to get money but no one work out for me each day I share tears, I was just looking out my family no money to take care of them until one day I decided to join the great Illuminati , I come across them in the internet I never believe I said let me try I email them.all what they said we happen in my life just started it was like a dream to me they really change my story totally . They give me the sum of $1,000,000 and many thing. through the Illuminati I was able to become rich, and have many industry on my own and become famous and popular in my country , today me and my family is living happily and I am the most happiest man here is the opportunity for you to join the Illuminati and become rich and famous in life and be like other people and you life we be change totally. If you are interested in joining the great brotherhood Illuminati contact this number call +2348163028633 or WhatsApp the same number +2348163028633 or email illuminatiworldoffamous@gmail.com

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments