Broke: Who Killed the Middle Classes? by David Boyle

Stewart Lansley on claims that the bourgeois advance is stuck in reverse

July 11, 2013

The latest group of Britons to face the backlash of destabilising economic and social change is, according to Broke, the middle class. The growth of a sizeable professional elite – across the rich world – has been one of the most enduring trends of the past century. David Boyle’s thesis – bulging with implications and certainly timely – is that this rise has come to a juddering halt.

The idea that the middle classes are in trouble has been well charted in the US, with a string of books such as It’s the Middle Class, Stupid! (2012). Here the evidence is clear-cut. The US led the way in the middle-class explosion, but is the first nation to allow this trend to reverse. The size of Middle America – stung by decades of near-stagnant wages and opportunities – has shrunk by about a quarter since the late 1970s.

Broke argues that the British middle classes – facing a tightening squeeze on schools, mortgages, universities and pensions – are facing a similar decline. However, the US evidence is not directly transferable. The US middle has a literal meaning, the group straddling the mid-point of the income ladder. While Boyle does not provide a rigorous definition, he is referring to a different group, namely well-paid professionals higher up the income ladder, below the enriched 1 per cent but mostly above the “squeezed middle”, the latter perhaps the nearest equivalent we have to the American middle.

The main losers from today’s crisis are those on middle and lower incomes, a group acknowledged here, but only in passing

Most of us know formerly well-heeled professionals who have fallen on hard times, and if we don’t, Boyle offers plenty of sympathetic examples. Indeed, the book relies heavily on such anecdotes. It has the feel of a highly personal lament, albeit an eloquent one, for the loss of the virtues of a class of which he is part, for the end of “what the middle classes believe they stand for – education, culture, leadership, perhaps also imagination…and the ability to think for yourself”.

Lament and anecdote, however, are not enough to support a thesis as potentially profound as this. There is a considerable body of evidence, mostly ignored in this book, on the winners and losers from recent upheavals. The UK is a multispeed nation, with a majority in the slow lane, some in the fast lane (mostly the middle class in the top 15-20 per cent of incomes) and the 1 per cent on the superhighway. While some parts of the professional classes are facing a whittling away of privileges, this is in part because of intergenerational redistribution. Many of today’s working-age generation, middle- and non-middle-class alike, are simply paying for the crown jewels grabbed in the post-war era by many of those in or close to retirement, a serious imbalance no one seems willing to correct. But this is the middle class of one age group eating the middle class of another.

How to manage the emergence of near-stagnant living standards and the end of an era of rising prosperity and choices for most is fast becoming one of the most pressing issues of the day. But while forecasts of the dying of the middle class would indeed be bad news, not just for them but for economic growth and political stability, they can be overdone. The main losers from today’s spreading crisis of opportunity and livelihood are those on middle and lower incomes, a group acknowledged here, but only in passing. Some parts of the middle classes are being caught in this whirlwind of change, and the current generation will have it tougher than their parents and grandparents, but they remain a good deal better protected than most of the rest.

Broke: Who Killed the Middle Classes?

By David Boyle
Fourth Estate, 352pp, £14.99
ISBN 9780007491032
Published 25 April 2013

Already registered?

Sign in now if you are already registered or a current subscriber. Or subscribe for unrestricted access to our digital editions and iPad and iPhone app.

Reader's comments (1)

(On the middle classes) "the ability to think for yourself" Oh that is funny! You have been shepherded through an indoctrination (aka education) system which rewards nothing other than compliance. The sole object is to make you a wage slave, sometimes a "well-off" wage slave but still a wage slave. Intellectual freedom doesn't even enter into it.

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Featured Jobs

User Acceptance Testing Technician CAMBRIDGE ASSESSMENT
Director of Teaching and Learning UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF ENGLAND
Director of Learning and Teaching UNIVERSITY OF GREENWICH (MAIN ADDRESS)

Register to continue  

You've enjoyed reading five THE articles this month. Register now to get five more, or subscribe for unrestricted access.

Most Commented

Globalisation

Times Higher Education World University Rankings data reveal the top 200 most outward-looking institutions

Common cactus finch (Geospiza scandens)

Tiffany Taylor on a thought-provoking view of the forces acting to ensure survival

Stressed businessman answering four telephones

Some surveys show faculty putting in at least 60 hours a week, but research casts doubt on whether this is a productive routine

Student asking question during class

University of Reading research finds link between undergraduate satisfaction and ethnicity of lecturers

Level of quality compass

Authors argue this means universities should spend less on senior academics and give promising younger scholars more of a chance