Book of the week: Beauty and Education

A paean to teaching's role in the good society wins Fred Inglis' heart

April 1, 2010

The good society, as William Morris imagined it in News from Nowhere, would be one in which the useful would be beautiful and the dreadful drudgery of industrial labour would be transformed into happy and fulfilling craftsmanship. One way of reminding ourselves of the necessity of utopian thinking may be for us to imagine a corner of such a society as being one where vice-chancellors, instead of gibbering about "outcomes", "excellence" and the fatuity of "impact", sat down quietly and read Joe Winston's splendid little book.

He opens with a wince-making anecdote about sitting in a warm circle with his colleagues to share (as they say) plans for future research with which to guarantee gratifying outcomes. When it came to Winston's turn, and he said he intended that rather than reporting findings, he was going to think and read about beauty, he was greeted with incredulous sniggering.

The tale is typical of the man and his book. He moves easily and with a deep, modest sincerity between fragments of autobiography, recollecting without condescension and with amusement his efforts to mimic Bob Dylan, cap and all, almost 40 years ago, and then turning to affecting little episodes in which schoolchildren by way of the arts of performance and their excellent teachers' guidance discover beauty, its truth and its goodness, which they can still love spontaneously, and which the hideous strength of their mad computer games and revolting DVDs daily traduce in the name of profit.

But the autobiographical interpolations, always brief and nicely judged, are set in a foreground behind which tower the great ranges of the history of the idea of beauty, never foreshortened, justly surveyed and measured up.

He begins from the present and Roger Scruton's crazily partisan effort on television to persuade us that beauty is to be found only in its past forms, an ideological polemic that traps its author in bad faith, unable to distinguish between life and death. Winston's larger purpose, however, is to sort among the ancestors and discover what of their conceptions is still a living deposit in his large and contradictory concept.

In essence, this becomes a duel between Plato and Immanuel Kant, both still thriving in our sensibilities: Winston has us now incline towards the sensuous coincidence of desire and beauty (Plato), now towards the sterner admonitions of Kantian disinterestedness and impersonality. He has read a lot and, like the good teacher he is, tells us on the way of those who most helped him sort out the argument.

The best of these are Alexander Nehamas, John Armstrong and Elaine Scarry, whose admirable essay On Beauty and Being Just gives the lie both to Scruton and to Winston's more egregious colleagues, as well as indicating to us that something important is stirring in the body academic that may yet quicken it to throw off some of the deathly corpulence and blood-stopping jargon of corporate pedagogy, never more ghastly than in an unbelievable-sounding book called Building Learning Power, here guillotined in one paragraph.

But Winston's heart is most caught and held by the small repeated beauties of children at their playful education, discovering and creating with easy or effortful negligence the fragile expressiveness that they will either carry forward in their souls for a lifetime or see blotted out by the saccharine emissions of kitsch and capitalism.

Winston acknowledges, as he must, the full-throated assault of high modernism - of Picasso, Stravinsky, T.S. Eliot and Otto Dix - upon the old sumptuaries of beauty and in the name of the terrible 20th century. But he is restored, perhaps even a bit too easily, by the human resilience argued for by two grand old stalwarts, John Dewey and Michael Oakeshott, and their faith in the touchstone of experience.

Teachers have always made rather too much of this latter concept, and Winston is quick to insist on its active, constructive and world-making force, particularly in the use to which he puts Richard Sennett's instant classic, The Craftsman (he really is very well read; it shows in his beautifully - ha! - chosen epigraphs).

Sennett, however, leads him unexpectedly to The History Boys and to the craftily affecting moment at which Alan Bennett turns the schoolteacher's craft into art, and leaves us with the tears and mortality of things. In Bennett's delicate masterpiece it comes via Thomas Hardy's poem Drummer Hodge; in Winston's parallel anecdote, with a teacher reading Oscar Wilde's The Selfish Giant to her six-year-olds, and breaking down before its beauty. A little boy takes the book from her hands and finishes reading it aloud to the class. "I always have to do that when she reads that story," he tells the inspector who is watching.

Winston is certain - as who among us would not be? - that such experiences of beauty are good for all humankind. He makes no heavy weather out of the cross-cultural varieties of beauty, calmly and rightly convinced as he is that enough of its mighty meaning survives its transit across vast geographies. The children who provide the large chorus in his social drama bear him out. They are after all both the society of the future and its students, a commonplace much overlooked by those university departments that treat their inferior colleagues in education with such unremitting condescension. The beauty these children encounter in their classrooms of childhood has consequences, in Winston's book and in history, for the possibility of the good society.

He finds glimpses of that society in football, horribly damaged though it is by sheer money. He finds more in that new and wonderful space in society now provided for the disabled and so movingly occupied by dancers and sculptors making loveliness out of deformation. He gets a bit needlessly tangled up in the relations of creativity with beauty, siding rightly with Morris and John Ruskin but getting a bit lost in some rather muffled pages on creativity and communication, and some worthy, not obviously relevant stuff on how to produce the first scene of Hamlet.

He tops this off with judicious, dogged afterthoughts on beauty in science, very properly helped out by Richard Holmes on the scientific Romantics before closing with, bless its creator and his creation, a day's earnest botanising at the infinitely beautiful Eden Project in Cornwall.

If this isn't exactly a beautiful book, its author certainly has a beautiful nature - a tribute that can sound embarrassing only if the academics have indeed and wholly abandoned their vocation and are in thrall to the corporate robots. This is a strong, awkward and courageous piece of work. Its author is dauntingly sincere, wide open but well armed with intelligence and deep reading and his own unmistakable goodness of disposition. Crazy and piratical as Routledge's price is, this book will prove welcome ammunition for the intellectual commando in the hills, fighting on behalf of the nation's virtue.

The author

Joe Winston is associate professor (reader) in education at the University of Warwick's Institute of Education.

Before joining the institution in 1991, he worked as a class teacher and then head teacher at a Devonshire middle school. He remains in touch with that sector by regularly working with schools and teachers within the UK and abroad.

Winston is co-editor of Research in Drama Education: The Journal of Applied Theatre and Performance, and his previous writings on the educational value of beauty have appeared in the Journal of Moral Education (2006) and the Journal of Aesthetic Education (2008).

Away from work and research, Winston likes coastal walks and makes regular visits to London to see his two children. He also enjoys outings to the theatre and reading novels that "take you on such an emotional journey that, upon completion, you feel it was well worth the effort".

A fan of Liverpool Football Club, Winston especially enjoys watching the Spanish striker Fernando Torres in action.

He admits, however, that the team is unlikely to finish among the Premier League's top four and thus secure qualification for the European Champions League next season.

"If we win all of our remaining games, we have a chance...but I wouldn't bet my money on this happening!"

Beauty and Education

By Joe Winston Routledge

186pp, £70.00

ISBN 9780415994903

Published 18 December 2009.

You've reached your article limit.

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments