Exit wound: Jo Johnson quitting hurts PM and raises HE policy questions

John Morgan looks at why the universities and science minister’s comeback was so short and what his exit means

September 5, 2019
Jo Johnson
Source: Reuters
Not just a number: overseas students should be seen as an asset, not a migration statistic, says Jo Johnson

A mere six weeks after it began, Jo Johnson’s comeback as universities and science minister is over. After being reappointed to the post when the new prime minister, his brother Boris, entered Number 10, Jo Johnson tweeted today that in “recent weeks I’ve been torn between family loyalty and the national interest – it’s an unresolvable tension & time for others to take on my roles as MP & Minister”. His exit as minister is immediate, while he will stand down as an MP at the next election.

It always seemed baffling that Jo Johnson, an ardent campaigner for Remain in the EU referendum, who had warned that a no deal Brexit would “inflict untold damage on our nation”, had ostensibly signed up to the commitment to back a no deal Brexit demanded of ministers in the new government.

Presumably, Jo Johnson – who remained closely engaged with higher education policy after his first resignation over Brexit, as transport minister for the Theresa May government – thought there were some key things he could achieve in the short term in the universities and science brief, notably helping to bury the Augar review and to revive post-study work visas for international students.

His exit inflicts a political wound on Boris Johnson and raises questions about some key policy issues in higher education.

On the wider politics, one of the traumatic aspects for Jo Johnson in taking this decision must have been the knowledge that he was giving Labour an easy line of attack on his brother.

Angela Rayner, the shadow education secretary, said in a press release issued rapidly after the announcement: “Boris Johnson poses such a threat that even his own brother doesn’t trust him.”

She added: “We have now had four higher education ministers in two years – just the latest sign of the chaos that the Tories have caused to education and the threat that a disastrous no deal Brexit poses to our colleges and universities.”

Of the last four Tory universities ministers, Greg Clark and Sam Gyimah have been expelled from the party this week for rebelling against the government, while Jo Johnson is to quit as an MP.

Boris Johnson’s purge of Tory moderates from the party, after the rebels supported a bill to force the government to remove the immediate threat of a no deal Brexit, appears to have been the trigger for Jo Johnson’s move.

ITV journalist Robert Peston tweeted that Jo Johnson had told colleagues “how upset he was at purging of Tory MPs” like former education secretary Justine Greening and Ken Clarke, “to whom he is closer politically in many ways than to his brother, especially on Brexit”.

There were suggestions on Twitter that Jo Johnson may return to his old employer, the Financial Times, as editor.

In policy terms, Jo Johnson may have pretty well achieved his short-term goal of seeing off the Augar review’s plan to lower fees to £7,500, which universities feared would mean big funding cuts (Augar was not mentioned in the chancellor’s spending review this week, which the last government had said would contain its response).

And there are suggestions that an announcement on the return of post-study work visas for international students, for which Jo Johnson had already laid much of the groundwork from the backbenches, is expected soon. Whether today’s developments change that remains to be seen.

Jo Johnson’s exit comes as the Department for Education considers its response to the review of the teaching excellence framework – policy Jo Johnson personally created – by Dame Shirley Pearce. The government has digested the review, which includes a consideration of the merits or otherwise of moving to a subject-level exercise. But the process of publishing a response to the review will now be held up as someone patiently explains to the new minister what the TEF is.

Given that Jo Johnson was the most pro-EU minister in the new government, his successor will inevitably bring a shift in attitudes on Brexit. A Brexiteer in the universities and science job would worry the sector, given its hopes that the government will be willing to pay the EU to join its research and Erasmus programmes after Brexit.

So we await the appointment of the next universities and science minister, assuming there is such an appointment given the likely proximity of an election. Whoever they turn out to be, recent history suggests that we shouldn’t get too attached to them.

John Morgan is deputy news editor at Times Higher Education

Please login or register to read this article.

Register to continue

Get a month's unlimited access to THE content online. Just register and complete your career summary.

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

Related articles

Reader's comments (3)

... there are many who the only way to keep their job is not do their job. this is a man who wants to do his job and if situation makes that difficult is prepared to pull back rather than go along just to get along A hero one would say. Basil Jide fadipe.
Jo Johnson has been an honest Politician in an increasingly challenging situation. We need more such Politicians who live by their convictions .
My life was destroyed when my husband sent me packing, after 13 years we have been together. I was lost and helpless after trying so many ways to my husband back to me. One day at work, I was distracted, not knowing that my boss called me, so he sat and asked me what it was all about, I told him and he smiled and said it was no problem. I never understood what he meant by it was no problem getting back my husband, he said he used a spell to get back his wife when she left him for another man, and now they are together till date and initially I was shocked hearing something from my boss. He gave me an email address of the LORD NOBEL which helped him get his wife back, I never believed that this would work, but I had no choice coming into contact with the sayings that I get done, and he asked for my information and that my husband was able to propose to throw him the spell and I sent him the details, but after two days, my mother called me that my husband was pleading that he wants me back, I never believed, because it was just a dream and I had to rush off to my mother's place and to my greatest surprise, was kneeling my husband beg me for forgiveness that he wants me and the child back home, when I gave LORD NOBEL a conversation regarding sudden change of my husband and he made clear to me that my husband will love me until the end of the world, that he will never leave for another woman. Now me and my husband is back together and started doing funny things he has not done before, he makes me happy and do what it is supposed to do as a man without nagging. Please if you need help of any kind need, please contact LORD NOBEL for help. His email is lordnoblespellcaster@hotmail.com or lordnoblespellcaster@gmail.com or you can call or whatspp him on this number + 1(817)755-0129

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Most commented

Sponsored

Featured jobs