Creative rigour

June 22, 2017

Does Paul G. Ellis really believe that a PhD in creative writing does not involve “intense intellectual capability and effort” (Letters, 15 June)? I am sure that he is familiar with the Quality Assurance Agency’s Subject Benchmark Statement for creative writing, which establishes what is required at BA level in creative writing and can extrapolate from that to gauge what might be required at MA and PhD levels in terms of “academic integrity”.

I am assuming that he must also have looked at some PhDs in creative writing. In case he has not, I would like to offer two of my current PhDs as examples. One is engaged in practice-based research into home, displacement and memory. This will produce a volume-length sequence of poems exploring this area. The candidate will also produce a 40,000-word dissertation, which, in the first year of research, has involved, in addition to literary critical work on the poetry of Carolyn Forché, extensive reading in the theorisation of space and an engagement with Derridean hauntology.

The other, working on the poetry of disaster, besides developing her practice-based research in this field and exploring the literature of disaster, has spent some of her first year taking an MA module on disaster theory to equip herself with the disciplinary framework for the 40,000-word dissertation that she will write.

Ellis seems to privilege “logic and maths” as the only forms of intellectual and academic integrity – as the only forms of knowledge and knowledge production. Practice-based research has long been accepted as a form of knowledge production. Fiction, poetry and other creative work produce knowledge and challenge the privileging of “logic”. Ellis’ apparent ignorance of the master of fine arts degree – and of the difference between the MFA and the PhD in creative writing – suggest that his research in this area has been something less than rigorous.

Robert Hampson
Director of the MA in creative writing
Royal Holloway, University of London

Send to

Letters should be sent to:
Letters for publication in Times Higher Education should arrive by 9am Monday.
View terms and conditions.

Please login or register to read this article.

Register to continue

Get a month's unlimited access to THE content online. Just register and complete your career summary.

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments

Reader's comments (2)

Reply to follow...
Finally, the promised reply, together with indications of a possible longer reply, all assuming Professor Hampson’s rejoinder was not simply postmodern irony: The short reply: virtually every one of the above assertions can be countered, on the basis of: a) Detailed considerations from over 100 references (listed below), unfortunately needing more time and space to present coherently than is available at present. b) Unexpectedly, perhaps: significant personal experience of the performance world, both semi-professional and professional (in addition to STEM-type research to post-doc’ level), including: o employment in a PhD-awarding performing arts institution, for some years o elsewhere, a close (but strictly-professional) working relationship with a creative writer who’s been awarded a PhD in that subject o a modest amount of published and unpublished creative writing (some even of a hauntological character) plus a considerable body of academic editing. The long reply requires completion of what might prove to be a novel line of argument exploiting distinctions between natural and formal languages, also augmented by some of the listed references. “To a teacher of postmodern thought there comes a time when the world is but a place of many words and man appears a mere talking animal not much more wonderful than a parrot.” (with apologies to Conrad.) REFERENCES (URLs may not work here, but most items can be googled) 130215 - Salzburg-principles-2005.pdf 1-the-florence-principles20161124105336_20161202112511.pdf 2000 StudHE The academic qualities of practice.pdf 21 May 2015 | Times Higher Education (THE) Abstract Objects and the Semantics of Natural Language - Oxford Scholarship A-level axe for creative writing prompts fury | Times Higher Education (THE) Are you smarter than a fiction writer? | Writing fiction: a balancing act BBC Horizon Battle of the Brains - YouTube [720p].mp4 Can_philosophy_survive_THES_2010-Dec-2015.pdf Chinese overview (mathematics) Creative writing - Wikipedia Creative Writing MFA degree course - London postgraduate courses - Kingston University London Creativity and Affect (Creativity Research): Melvin Shaw, Mark Runco: 9781567500127: Books Dawkins Review of Intellectual Impostures Definition of Creative Writing Developing Provably-Correct Software Using Formal Methods Disaster Theory: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Concepts and Causes - David Etkin - Google Books Do people win Nobel Prizes for work during their PhD? Doctoral_Programmes_Project_Report.1129278878120.pdf Douglas Arvidson: The Writer's Blogs 2005 to the Present: I.Q. and Creativity: Are You Smart Enough to Be a Writer? early indian maths - Google Search Establishing Creative Writing Studies as an Academic Discipline Fashionable Nonsense - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Fitch's paradox of knowability - Wikipedia Formal and Natural Languages — How to Think like a Computer Scientist: Interactive Edition Frascati Manual 2015: Guidelines for Collecting and Reporting Data on Research and Experimental Development Frascati Manual: Proposed Standard Practice for Surveys on Research and Experimental Development, 6th edition - OECD Fritz Mauthner | German theatre critic and philosopher | Gender, Space and Time: Women and Higher Education - Dorothy Moss - Google Books Gödel and the limits of logic | goedel - How does Gödel's theorem apply to daily life? - Philosophy Stack Exchange Hauntology - Wikipedia H Frankfurt On Bullshit (Princeton, 2005).pdf Hauntology_in_the_Age_of_the_Otolith_Gro.docx How French “Intellectuals” Ruined the West: Postmodernism and Its Impact, Explained – Areo Magazine How to make an original contribution to knowledge | University Affairs impact.pdf Is Science an Ideology? | Issue 15 | Philosophy Now Jacques Derrida - Wikipedia Knowledge - Wikipedia Like Math? Thank Your Motivation, Not IQ - Scientific American Logocentrism - Wikipedia Ludwig Wittgenstein - Wikipedia Martin Heidegger - Wikipedia Medicine - Wikipedia Medieval university - Wikipedia Meritocracy, Cognitive Ability, and the Sources of Occupational Success Microsoft Word - PBR guide2006-1.1 motivation_not_IQ__Murayama1_et_al.pdf Murayama Maths growth.pdf Necessary limits to knowledge: unknowable truths | SpringerLink new variant phd.pdf OECD Frascati Manual 9215001e.pdf Philosophy News | What is Knowledge? Philosophy of language - Wikipedia poetry may be truer than science - for certain purposes. - Google Search Poetry of disaster importance.docx Postmodernism vs. Science, Shermer, Scientific American Sept 2017 postmodernism | philosophy | Postmodernism, Ideology and Rationality | Post-structuralism - Wikipedia Predicting Long-Term Growth in Students' Mathematics Achievement: The Unique Contributions of Motivation and Cognitive Strategies - Murayama - 2012 - Child Development - Wiley Online Library Presidential Lectures: Jacques Derrida: Richard Rorty essay Principles_for_Innovative_Doctoral_Training.pdf Professor Liam Hudson - Telegraph Project MUSE - Samuel Beckett and the Postmodern: Language Games, Play and <i>Waiting for Godot</i> RAE 2001 : Submissions Response to Withdrawal of Creative Writing at A-Level — University of Leicester Richard Feynman’s Philosophy of Science | Issue 114 | Philosophy Now Richard Rorty .docx Rudolf Mössbauer - Wikipedia Salzburg_II_Recommendations Samuel Beckett, Fritz Mauthner, and the Limits of Language on JSTOR SBS-Creative-Writing-16.pdf Scientists outshine arts students with experiments in creative writing | Books | The Guardian Selecting for superficiality Zubatov (THES).docx Winter, Griffiths & Green (2000)The_%27Academic%27_Qualities_of_Practice_What_are_the_criteria_for_a_practice-based_PhD Show or Tell | The New Yorker stern-ref-review Students - Research - Creative Writing - Department - Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences - Kingston University London THE 100 (Analysed simply).xlsx The arts - Wikipedia The Complete Idiot's Guide to Creative Writing, 2nd edition - Laurie Rozakis - Google Books The link between a high IQ and high creativity! The Mathematical Sciences: A Report - National Research Council (U.S.). Committee on Support of Research in the Mathematical Sciences - Google Books The New Wittgenstein - Wikipedia The Professional Quest for Truth: A Social Theory of Science and Knowledge - Stephan Fuchs - Google Books The Service of Statistics to History on JSTOR The Sham Ph.D. | myGraduateSchool Blog The Social Sciences Collection » Deconstruction of Knowledge Nature in the Views of Derrida and Feyerabend: The Possibility and Necessity of Interdisciplinary Studies in Higher Education There’s one key difference between kids who excel at math and those who don’t — Quartz TP Msg: #1580 Different Views of Intelligence [] - - Gmail Tracy K. Smith MFA (He & me, THE 20-26 July 2017, p. 22) J von Uexkull.doc Universities are dumbing down, say lecturers | Education | The Guardian US National Education Longitudinal Study of 1988.pdf Western philosophy - Contemporary philosophy | What is Godel's Theorem? - Scientific American What is the relationship between the works of later Wittgenstein and Postmodernism? Or is there even any? : askphilosophy which-worse-postmodernism-or-anti-intellectualism-11040 Wisconsin Men's Henmon-Nelson IQ Distributions for 1992-94 Occupation Groups with 30 Cases or More - Google Search wittgenstein/postmodern philosophy Wittgenstein versus Mauthner: Two critiques of language, two mysticisms Wittgenstein: Two Philosophies? - Philosophy Philosophizing Writing for Times Higher Education | Times Higher Education (THE)

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Most commented