When lecturers are asked who they look to for academic leadership, they cite colleagues and even dead people - but not their own managers.
That is one possible message to be drawn from research by the Leadership Foundation for Higher Education, an organisation established by Universities UK and GuildHE.
The study, led by researchers at the University of Exeter, calls for academics to develop a "collective voice" at a time when the profession is under immense pressure.
It concludes that bodies such as UUK and the University and College Union do not meet this need.
The researchers analysed the views of 350 academics and found a common observation that academic leadership "is not provided by people in formal managerial roles".
Instead, lecturers say, the role is filled by PhD supervisors, former colleagues and leading academics in their field, whether or not they are part of the same institution.
The view of one academic at a post-1992 university consulted in the research, cited at the launch event for the study last week, gives a clear perspective on the sources of academic leadership: "People I've never met, mostly - some of them dead," she said.
In conclusion, the study - titled Academic Leadership: Changing Conceptions, Identities and Experiences in UK Higher Education - offers a series of possible ways forward.
For example, university managers "anxious to encourage high levels of performance" would be best advised to "step back from mechanistic managerial approaches, and to emphasise instead the values associated with academic excellence".
Other concluding principles include the need to "engage with academics as professionals" instead of as a human resource to be applied in the service of students or "customers".
Universities are also advised to "safeguard 'membership' of the academic community", a principle that may be at odds with the changing higher education landscape, the study acknowledges. "Competition between universities will become characteristic of the sector, driving attempts by management to emphasise academics' loyalty to the institution rather than their scholarly disciplines and networks," it says.
"However, we should reiterate that we found little sense that academics generally identify with their employing institution.
"Brand management is therefore seen as largely irrelevant for academic leadership."
The study also advocates the necessity of creating "a collective voice" for academics.
It says of current sector bodies that "none of them represent the voice of academics as distinct from the managerial concerns of institutions.
"Universities UK represents universities as managed institutions; the Universities and Colleges Employers Association speaks for them as employers."
The study adds that the UCU "now has such a broad membership that it cannot really speak for academics per se, and neither the British Academy or the Royal Society have sought to publicly represent the identity and values of academia."
The study concedes it is "doubtful that academics would recognise any external agency speaking for them" as its research shows that "leadership is associated with close colleagueship, and not with representative structures.
"It is more likely that we will see the appearance of 'accidental leaders', people whose personal stories epitomise the predicament, ideals and hopes of academics."
But the study adds that "we have no examples of this at the moment; rather we seem to be in a leadership lacuna at the collective level".
The study was carried out by Richard Bolden, Jonathan Gosling, Anne O'Brien, Kim Peters, Michelle Ryan and Alex Haslam of Exeter, with Luz Longsworth of the University of the West Indies and Anna Davidovic and Kathrin Winkleman, two former Exeter postgraduates.
Register to continue
Get a month's unlimited access to THE content online. Just register and complete your career summary.
Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:
- Sign up for the editor's highlights
- Receive World University Rankings news first
- Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
- Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Or subscribe for unlimited access to:
- Unlimited access to news, views, insights & reviews
- Digital editions
- Digital access to THE’s university and college rankings analysis
- Unrestricted access to the UK and global edition of the THE app on IOS, Android and Kindle Fire
Already registered or a current subscriber? Sign in now