Advancement rests on research record

May 28, 2015

You report that a black philosopher claims that he was rejected for a full-time job because his proposed black studies course was too challenging to white-dominated academia (“New MA ‘too critical of white hegemony’ ”, News, 21 May). I find Nathaniel Adam Tobias

Coleman’s protestations utterly unconvincing: there is no way that anyone with a two-year-old PhD and not a single peer-reviewed publication could be offered a permanent job at University College LondonColeman should consider himself very lucky to have been offered a coveted postdoc at a prestigious institution with his research record.

Priscilla Ahern

 I am a philosophy student at UCL and I am disappointed that Coleman’s contract will not be renewed. This is especially unfortunate considering that philosophy is a discipline with such a dismal record of recognising the work of non-white scholars.

Klara Andersson

 I think this is a prime example of the issues in academia highlighted in the “Why is my curriculum white?” movement. Coleman could provide a much-needed critical voice to another unquestioned curriculum (and institution) that maintains colonial white discourses (and faces). And his proposed MA would begin to allow for wider perspectives to enter this “prestigious institution”. However, it seems that UCL’s pledge towards “further progress in diversity” is contingent on its remaining inoffensive to existing privileged [scholars]. As a former member of staff at UCL, I am disappointed. As a woman of mixed race, I am offended. And as someone who would jump to be part of that MA course, I am heartbroken.

Sara Felix

 The #whitecurriculum campaign has had more impact than most peer-reviewed articles ever have. The fact that UCL will not give Coleman a permanent position, despite his demonstrable expertise and influence in instigating a public debate on white supremacy within philosophy and UK academia as a whole, is just more evidence of the problem that his work (and the work of all academics and students challenging institutional racism in academia) seeks to address.

Terese Jonsson

 Let me see if I can get this straight:

1) Academia needs more black/non-white voices – agreed.

2) Philosophy is too white – agreed.

Here’s the bit where it all falls to pieces for me. Because of the above points, an academic who has failed to publish a single peer-reviewed piece should be given a full-time permanent job without a competitive application process? That is what is being argued here. Challenging and breaking down racism in the academy isn’t done by rewarding mediocrity or by “jobs for the boys” because, ironically, simply giving a job to this man reinforces [higher education’s] gender problem. Someone applying for a full-time lecturer post at my lowly post-92 wouldn’t even get shortlisted without publications. Also, people need to knock off with “demonstrated expertise” – we have a way of demonstrating that in the academy. At the moment people are just relying on the idea of false authority – “he’s an expert because we say he’s an expert”.

Alan Smithee

 A strong peer-reviewed publication record is regarded as essential for getting a permanent job, and by such criteria Coleman would be unlikely to get a position at UCL or anywhere else. However, let’s not pretend that number of publications is an infallible or objective measure. Also, I’d like to know more about the process by which UCL decided against running the proposed MA. Was that to do with Coleman’s publication record? It’s a separate issue really, and I don’t think one can deny that UCL, like the academy in general, is reluctant to confront the issues that Coleman deals with in his teaching and non peer-reviewed publications.

Harry Stopes

You've reached your article limit

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 6 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Most Commented

United Nations peace keeper

Understanding the unwritten rules of graduate study is vital if you want to get the most from your PhD supervision, say Kevin O'Gorman and Robert MacIntosh

David Parkins Christmas illustration (22 December 2016)

A Dickensian tale, set in today’s university

Eleanor Shakespeare illustration (5 January 2017)

Fixing problems in the academic job market by reducing the number of PhDs would homogenise the sector, argues Tom Cutterham

poi, circus

Kate Riegle van West had to battle to bring her circus life and her academic life together

Houses of Parliament, Westminster, government

There really is no need for the Higher Education and Research Bill, says Anne Sheppard