Critic of Aids programme rejected as Natal vice-chancellor

April 19, 2002

South African scientist Malegapuru Makgoba, a critic of his government's stance on HIV-Aids, has been rejected as vice-chancellor of the University of Natal.

A university selection committee sought and shortlisted Professor Makgoba, president of the country's Medical Research Council, for the job. Although he was the sole candidate, he did not get the two-thirds backing needed from the -member committee.

He had agreed to stand as a candidate for the job vacated by Brenda Gourley, now vice-chancellor of Britain's Open University, only when asked to by the committee. "I agreed because I felt honoured to be asked by my alma mater, because Natal is a good university and because I have a great interest in higher education," he told The THES .

He is waiting to be given reasons for the decision, which the university is obliged to do. "Before that, I can't really comment on it."

Professor Makgoba may have become entangled in a dispute between the government and universities that are likely to be involved in a round of mergers.

Education minister Kader Asmal has said he does not want institutions involved in possible mergers to make senior appointments, but Natal advertised the post as a full rather than short-term contract. Natal confirmed that the committee "took note" of similar remarks Mr Asmal made again last week. Mr Asmal is due to release a final report on mergers later this month.

The university council will meet next month to decide whether to continue trying to find a new head or to stick with David Maughan Brown as acting vice-chancellor.

This week, students and some academics said they were "dissatisfied" that the job did not go to Professor Makgoba - who is said to have gained 70 per cent support in a straw poll held to inform the committee. They also accused the committee of bias.

There has been speculation that some committee members opposed Professor Makgoba because of his run-in with 13 (mostly white) academics at the University of the Wi****ersrand amid a vice-chancellor's race in the 1990s. He eventually quit the contest.

Professor Makgoba has often been in trouble for criticising the government's controversial approach to HIV-Aids. The latest attack - by African National Congress election manager Peter Mokaba - was deeply worrying because it followed claims by Professor Makgoba and fellow scientists that they are being pressured not to challenge ANC views.

Please login or register to read this article

Register to continue

Get a month's unlimited access to THE content online. Just register and complete your career summary.

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments