Caricature of university president returned…in pieces

By Elizabeth Redden, for Inside Higher Ed

October 14, 2014

Source: George Rammell

It took 53 days for George Rammell to get back a sculpture that he had made caricaturing his university’s president, and when officials at British Columbia’s Capilano University finally returned it to him, it was in pieces.

“They gave it back to me all smashed up,” said Mr Rammell, a former instructor at Capilano whose sculpture was seized from the studio arts building last spring by university officials on the grounds that it constituted “harassment” of Kris Bulcroft, the president of Capilano.

He said: “They claim they had to destroy it in order to move it, which is absolutely ridiculous. I’ve moved it myself.”

The original sculpture, titled Blathering On in Krisendom, depicted the president and her poodle as ventriloquist’s dolls draped in an American flag and was conceived, as Mr Rammell explained it, as an “anti-monument” to the president in protest of her role in carrying out course cuts.

Dr Bulcroft oversaw the elimination of several programmes, including the studio arts course that Mr Rammell taught, in a process that was later deemed by British Columbia’s Supreme Court to be contrary to the province’s University Act in that Capilano’s senate was not consulted.

Mr Rammell described the original sculpture as an example of constitutionally protected caricature, but Jane Shackell, Capilano’s former board chair, ordered that it be confiscated from university property because it was, she said, being “used in a manner amounting to workplace harassment of an individual employee, intended to belittle and humiliate the president”.

In order to reclaim his artwork, Mr Rammell said that he signed an agreement that stated that he would be permitted to work on the piece in the studio arts building until his employment at the university ended on 31 July. After that time, he would remove the sculpture from campus and would not bring it back. Mr Rammell said that the agreement also stipulated that he would not display any photographs of the sculpture on campus until five years after the president’s retirement. (Mr Rammell declined to share the text of the agreement that he had signed but described its contents to Inside Higher Ed. Capilano officials declined to comment on the specific terms of the grievance agreement, which a university spokeswoman described as related to a personnel matter and was thus confidential.)

In compensation for the damages to the sculpture, Mr Rammell said that he had received the equivalent of four days’ teaching wages.

“In retrospect I should never have signed the stupid thing; I could have finished the sculpture without getting the heap back,” he said.

And finish the sculpture he has. The new sculpture, made up of pieces of the original as well as new components, was unveiled last week in an event at the Emily Carr University of Art and Design, in Vancouver. The piece has two faces, or fronts: a newly sculpted depiction of the president holding a mace backs up against the reassembled components of the original sculpture. Among the new elements of the sculpture, Mr Rammell said that a mace is intended to signify the trust placed in the university president, and a pen is intended to represent Dr Bulcroft’s “unilateral” signing authority in eliminating the studio arts and other Capilano programmes. The new piece is entitled Margaux and the Monarch, Margaux being the name of Dr Bulcroft’s dog.

As for the American flag, Dr Bulcroft previously worked at Western Washington University. Mr Rammell said that while he has nothing against international recruits, he did object to Dr Bulcroft’s seeming disregard for a Canadian law, specifically the University Act.

“The whole piece is about academic freedom and everybody seems to be under threat,” Mr Rammell said.

Dr Bulcroft declined an interview through Borjana Slipicevic, a Capilano spokeswoman. A statement emailed by Ms Slipicevic that repeatedly misspelt Mr Rammell’s name said that “Capilano University is aware of Mr Rammel’s current actions. The university is committed to a safe and respectful workplace for all faculty and staff; the decision to remove Mr Rammel’s sculpture from campus was made in this vein. Capilano University and Mr Rammel’s union negotiated a mutually acceptable settlement that resulted in giving the sculpture to Mr Rammell; thus Capilano University considers this matter closed.”

As for the condition of the sculpture upon its return, the university’s statement said: “The effigy was dismantled to facilitate its removal; Mr Rammel was advised that this was the case.”

In regard to the broader issue of consultation and shared governance, the statement said that the university is currently developing a new strategic plan for 2015-18: “This planning process is guided by our academic plan, which students, faculty, staff, the local community and other stakeholders helped develop over the course of the past year. The strategic plan will define our way forward for the next three years. We are engaging the people who will be most affected by the strategic plan – students, faculty and staff. We began this process in August and will continue through November, when a draft plan will be presented to the Capilano University Board of Governors.”

Brent Calvert, the president of Capilano’s Faculty Association, described the consultation process as being pro forma in nature. Discussion forums have been held at times when many staff teach, he said, depressing attendance for staff and students alike. Professor Calvert said he’s optimistic that the administration will agree to hold a forum during a designated weekly non-teaching block later this month. He added that, in any case, the time to incorporate substantive feedback is short. “We’re marching against an incredibly tight timeline,” he said.

The Canadian Association of University Teachers – an organisation that is analogous to the American Association of University Professors – is working on a report on the seizure of Mr Rammell’s sculpture and whether it violated his academic freedom. For his part, Mr Rammell said that he’s nearly ready to move on. At long last he considers the sculpture finished, and he said that he is ready to exhibit it and even put it on the market.

Inside Higher Ed’s reporter observed that Capilano could purchase it and hide it away.

He responded: “I wouldn’t let it go for less than $50,000 (£28,000).”

You've reached your article limit

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 6 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Featured Jobs

Professor-Keith Cameron Chair of Australian History UNIVERSITY COLLEGE DUBLIN (UCD)
Senior Procurement Officer UNIVERSITY OF THE WEST OF SCOTLAND
Clinician, Small Animal Emergency Services UNIVERSITY COLLEGE DUBLIN (UCD)
Director COVENTRY UNIVERSITY COLLEGE

Most Commented

question marks PhD study

Selecting the right doctorate is crucial for success. Robert MacIntosh and Kevin O'Gorman share top 10 tips on how to pick a PhD

India, UK, flag

Sir Keith Burnett reflects on what he learned about international students while in India with the UK prime minister

Pencil lying on open diary

Requesting a log of daily activity means that trust between the institution and the scholar has broken down, says Toby Miller

Construction workers erecting barriers

Directly linking non-EU recruitment to award levels in teaching assessment has also been under consideration, sources suggest

Microlight pilot flies with flock of cranes

Reports of UK-based researchers already thinking of moving overseas after Brexit vote