Journal rankings do not recognise quality (2 of 2)

January 20, 2011

As a struggling "new researcher" who has been encouraged by an experienced academic like Dennis Tourish (Letters, 13 January), I support his sentiments about the tyranny of journal rankings.

Here is a suggestion: the 19th-century French Impressionists rejected by the official Paris art salons set up a "salon des refusés" instead, and by showcasing their work eventually achieved legitimacy for the new style of painting. How about a "journal des refusés"? I'm sure many of us have the equivalent of a few journalistic Manets in the attic, rejected by the five-star critics but with similar potential for changing the academic establishment.

Mary Brown, Department of management Aberdeen Business School, Robert Gordon University.

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments