
Recognise the human behind the grade
Provision of a quality education goes beyond academic rigour and teaching qualifications. Equally important are recognition of when a student might be struggling, an understanding of how circumstances outside the classroom can affect academic performance and judgement-free support.
Students are not just names on a register. They are human beings whose personal and social circumstances don’t disappear when they enter the classroom. Mental health can significantly affect the academic experience. It is the number one reason students in the UK consider dropping out of university, according to a Transforming Access and Student Outcomes in Higher Education report.
If what happens beyond the classroom can affect whether a student succeeds academically, supporting them through difficult moments is also part of our responsibility as educators.
How can educators help struggling students?
Support begins before a student asks for help. At the start of your course, establish the classroom as a safe space free from disrespectful behaviour, violence and bullying.
Students should also know that they can reach out when a situation begins to affect their academic performance. We can reinforce this by reminding them that communication is always welcome and, when appropriate, by providing an additional way to get in touch.
But telling students they can reach out is only the first step. Answer queries promptly and acknowledge what they have shared to show students that you are taking their decision to reach out seriously.
Empathy and accountability can coexist
Student support does not have to impact academic standards. However, upholding these should not prevent us recognising that circumstances beyond a student’s control can affect their ability to meet them.
In exceptional circumstances, students should know that they can approach teaching staff and explore options for support at both programme and institutional levels.
The goal is not to eliminate responsibility but to provide a path that allows the student to continue taking responsibility while acknowledging their personal circumstances.
Notice warning signs and act on them
Not every student who is struggling will ask for help. Sometimes, the first indication that something might be wrong appears through academic behaviour.
A sudden decline in grades, repeated absences, missed assignments or a noticeable change in participation can have many explanations. When these changes become a pattern, check in.
How we approach the student can determine whether that conversation feels like an invitation to communicate or another reason to withdraw. Our first instinct might be to focus on the problem: “Why haven’t you been attending class?” or “Why haven't you submitted your work?” Those questions might be necessary but they do not always have to be the first ones we ask.
- Spotlight guide: Student support in the university classroom
- Five steps to prevent student disengagemen
- How can we model empathy in the classroom?
Instead of approaching from a position of authority, we can begin with curiosity: “I noticed you haven't been to class lately. Is everything OK? Is something affecting your ability to keep up with the course?” I learned the importance of this approach through two of my students.
Both had stopped submitting assignments. After two weeks, I decided to reach out. I sent each of them an email asking whether they were having trouble with the learning management system or whether something else was happening that they wanted to talk about. Both responded.
One student was dealing with a difficult family and legal situation that was preventing her attending class and submitting assignments on time. The other was going through a difficult period and had considered dropping out of the course.
During our conversations, both students identified something important: they wanted to continue but they believed that, given their circumstances, dropping out might be their only option.
Once they had identified continuation as their goal, we could explore different paths based on each student’s circumstances. My role was not to decide whether they should continue but to help them understand what options were available so they could determine how to move forward.
Know the limitations of your role
Supporting students in the classroom does not require us to solve every problem. We are educators, not mental health professionals, and recognition of the limitations of our role is fundamental.
Universities might offer counselling, psychological support or other resources but during a crisis, students might not remember these resources or know where to find them. A simple reminder can make these resources more visible.
We don’t need to diagnose students or become their therapists. Sometimes, the most responsible forms of support are listening, recognising when a situation goes beyond our role and connecting them with someone better equipped to help.
Students remain responsible for their academic performance. But our responsibility as educators extends beyond content delivery. We can maintain high expectations while recognising the human being behind the grade.
Brenda Cantú Guerrero is a lecturer at Tecnológico de Monterrey, Mexico.
If you would like advice and insight from academics and university staff delivered direct to your inbox each week, sign up for the Campus newsletter.

