Logic and superman

Logical Properties
October 26, 2001

In this lucid and provocative little book, Colin McGinn examines five logical concepts. Their orthodox treatment in the Russell-Quine tradition is often criticised for clashing with our speech and with the metaphysical facts. As a logical realist, McGinn takes logical properties and facts to be part of an independent realm, not reducible to the physical or the mental. His book is clear, direct, and well argued.

Identity is a single, indefinable relation. Identity relates each object (including sets, times, properties and fictional objects) to itself and obeys the indiscernibility of identicals. Its proper form is "x = y" - not "x is the same F as y"; those who think otherwise need to sharpen the singular terms in their identity statements (for example, to use "this frog" or "this collection of atoms" instead of just "this").

Existence is an indefinable property that can be predicated of individual entities (as in "I exist" or "Superman does not exist"). Existence is not properly expressed by the "for some x" quantifier, which also can be used to translate "Some superheros are fictional and do not exist"; to claim existence of some superheros, we have to say "For some x, x exists and x is a superhero."

Predicates are singular terms that refer to properties. So "red", instead of having multiple reference to all red objects, simply refers to the property of being red. McGinn sees this as more natural, and as better epistemically (since we are acquainted with redness but not with all red objects) and metaphysically (since facts typically involve objects and properties).

Necessity is a manner in which an object has a property. So necessity is a copula modifier (not a sentence operator or a predicate modifier); its proper form is "Socrates is-necessarily bald". Necessary truths are accommodated through "Proposition p is-necessarily true". Necessity is non-empirical (and thus objectionably queer to some philosophers) - but objective and known a priori.

Truth is a property of propositions - a property that bridges the world of propositions to the world of objects. The truth of a proposition has implications about what reality is like: if "snow is white" is true, then snow is white. But "true" is not redundant. Asserting "p is true" is stronger than just asserting p, because the former has a different logical form and different ontological commitments (since it refers to a proposition and predicates of it the property of being true). There also is the problem of truth-value gaps; an ethical emotivist may affirm "Pleasure is good" but deny that "Pleasure is good" is true.

McGinn has strange views about impossible objects. He tells us that round squares exist but could not be actual; I am confused about what this means. It seems more plausible to hold that "round square" does not refer to any entities. "Round squares do not exist", instead of denying actuality to entities called "round squares", just claims that no existing entities are literally both round and square. Apart from this, McGinn's book is generally very sensible.

Harry Gensler is professor of philosophy, John Carroll University, Cleveland, United States.

Logical Properties: Identity, Existence, Predication, Necessity, Truth

Author - Colin McGinn
ISBN - 0 19 924181 3
Publisher - Clarendon Press
Price - £17.99
Pages - 114

You've reached your article limit.

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 3 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Featured Jobs

Most Commented

Monster behind man at desk

Despite all that’s been done to improve doctoral study, horror stories keep coming. Here three students relate PhD nightmares while two academics advise on how to ensure a successful supervision

Sir Christopher Snowden, former Universities UK president, attacks ratings in wake of Southampton’s bronze award

opinion illustration

Eliminating cheating services, even if it were possible, would do nothing to address students’ and universities’ lack of interest in learning, says Stuart Macdonald

Female professor

New data show proportion of professors who are women has declined at some institutions

Reflection of man in cracked mirror

To defend the values of reason from political attack we need to be more discriminating about the claims made in its name, says John Hendry