Guesstimation: Solving the World's Problems on the Back of a Cocktail Napkin

While Tony Mann risks buying ice-cream that might melt, others puzzle over fridge insurance and health

June 5, 2008

On the first day of their studies, I ask our new mathematics undergraduates to estimate numerical solutions to unexpected problems - the number of piano tuners in the UK or the volume of all the human blood in the world. While questions such as these - called "Fermi problems" by physicists after the great nuclear physicist - may seem rather arbitrary, the point is that, with a little thought, one can give approximate answers that will be accurate to within an order of magnitude.

This is a useful life skill - we all have to make judgments based on approximations and "guesstimates". Only this week I had to decide whether it was worth buying a tub of my favourite, locally unobtainable ice-cream when it would have to survive a long journey home: my estimate of its speed of melting led me to take the risk (with happy outcome).

Similar thought processes might help one to decide whether to take out insurance on a new fridge or to evaluate the real risk underlying a medical scare story in the press. Employers sometimes use such questions to assess candidates for appointments, believing that they provide evidence of problem-solving skills.

Lawrence Weinstein and John A. Adam have compiled a useful book of such estimation problems. They range from serious questions about energy consumption and carbon emissions, through practical problems such as estimating the number of portable toilets required at mass events, to the frankly silly - could Spider-Man stop a runaway subway train or would the Sun generate more energy if it were composed of gerbils?

Their valuable introduction suggests ways to approach problems (beginning with Cliff Swartz's helpful methodology - "Step 1: Write down the answer") and working through some examples in detail. The explanation of the advantage of the geometric over the arithmetic mean is particularly illuminating. The bulk of the book consists of problems, for each of which a number of hints is given, and then the authors' solution or solutions. Appendices include a list of further examples, some useful numbers and formulae, and some reference dimensions (from the size of an atom to the Earth-Sun distance).

The puzzles draw on elementary mathematics, physics and chemistry but require little specialist knowledge. Those relating to environmental issues are particularly timely: the analysis of the amount of land required to grow corn to replace petrol by ethanol is devastating, and any reader who works through these examples will emerge with an excellent appreciation of the scale of our environmental problems.

There were places where I felt more discussion would have been useful - my students often learn most when a superficially plausible method of estimation gives a wrong answer (such as extrapolating from the number of blind piano tuners, found on the web, forgetting that a disproportionate number of blind people may tune pianos). The problems are often oriented towards the US rather than the UK, but that is of little importance: more of a problem for some readers may be the authors' jokes, of which I rather quickly tired, although I appreciated the accessible style of the book.

Not only is the ability to solve Fermi problems useful, but it is also empowering. My students gain enormous confidence when they find that they can accurately estimate the answer to apparently difficult questions. They also gain a feel for dimensions and orders of magnitude.

This book is a stimulating collection that will help the reader to reach informed judgments and will be a useful source of inspiration for mathematics and physics teachers: my only concern is that if my students have read it before they arrive at university, I may have to find a new approach to my first day's teaching.

Guesstimation: Solving the World's Problems on the Back of a Cocktail Napkin

By Lawrence Weinstein and John A. Adam
Princeton University Press
320pp
£11.95
ISBN 9780691129495
Published 1 May 2008

Already registered?

Sign in now if you are already registered or a current subscriber. Or subscribe for unrestricted access to our digital editions and iPad and iPhone app.

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Featured Jobs

Register to continue  

You've enjoyed reading five THE articles this month. Register now to get five more, or subscribe for unrestricted access.

Most Commented

Track runner slow off the starting blocks

Lack of independent working blamed for difficulties making the leap from undergraduate to doctoral work

Quality under magnifying glass

Hefce's new standards regime will enable universities to focus on what matters to students, says Susan Lapworth

Woman tearing up I can't sign

Schools and universities are increasingly looking at how improving personalities can boost social mobility. But in doing so, they may be forced to choose between teaching what is helpful, and what is true, says David Matthews

Door peephole painted as bomb ready to explode

It’s time to use technology to detect potential threats and worry less about outdated ideas of privacy, says Ron Iphofen

A keyboard with a 'donate' key

Richard Budd mulls the logic of giving money to your alma mater