What’s in a name?

The tricks and teases academics use to entice their readers: clichés, the Bard and the phrases of the moment  

August 3, 2016
shakespeare-typescript-to-be-or-not-to-be
Source: iStock

The title of a journal article is the first thing the reader sees, so it’s important that it gives the reader a clear sense of what is coming. However, academics often do precisely the opposite, using unusual words and expressions, or metaphors and questions, in a seemingly deliberate attempt to obfuscate the contents.

The titles that most irk me are those that awkwardly use tired clichés in an attempt to liven up the subject matter and entice the reader.

In his excellent paper on the subject, “Familiarity breeds: clichés in article titles”, Neville Goodman notes how clichés that begin in business schools slowly seep into politics, and eventually into the argot of lawyers, doctors and academics.

I have seen countless papers claiming that something is dead, so long live another thing, while topics that have been described as a “perfect storm” range from “alcohol and caffeine” to “sleep in adolescents”.

As a researcher on ocean issues, I’ve seen a lot of rising tides and shifting sands. I’ll concede that “Leading a sea change in naval ship design” is a cute title, but I have an unreasonably visceral reaction to “A rising tide meets a perfect storm: new accountabilities in teaching and teacher education in Ireland”.

A few studies have been conducted into such titles. One of the earliest, a 2002 piece by Philip Atkin, was published in the British Medical Journal’s Christmas issue. This issue is usually dedicated to spoofs and parodies, and I assume this explains Atkin’s apparent enthusiasm for clichés: “Papers with catchy titles work best. Titles need to contain phrases that are in popular use and suggest innovation and exploration”.

Atkin analysed the use of two of the most popular clichés of the day: “paradigm shift” and “pushing the envelope”. Paradigm shifts were initially fairly unpopular, but began to find favour in the mid-1980s. A period of exponential growth followed before a steep decline toward the noughties. Likewise, few studies were pushing envelopes early on, but then in the 1990s they started to take a real beating.

Again with presumably sarcastic exuberance, Atkin urges academics to use new and exciting words and phrases in paper titles: “We must not confine our meditations but should begin to think outside of the box”.

Atkin’s nod to thinking outside the box was prescient: Goodman’s later analysis showed that the phrase first appeared in 1995 and 124 papers used it in the period 2006-2010.

Frequency of clichés used in titles of academic papers (from Goodman, 2012)

   

State of the art

3,518

Gold standard

915

Paradigm shift

722

Cutting edge

411

Outside the box

200

Wind of change

184

Coalface/goalposts/playing field

164

Pushing the envelope

86

Quantum leap

48

Rubber hits the road

23

But clichés are just the tip of the iceberg. Goodman conducted another study of titles, “From Shakespeare to Star Trek and beyond”, this time finding more than 1,400 Shakespearean allusions (a third of these are to “What's in a name”, and another third to Hamlet).

“To Clone or Not to Clone” appeared in 1997, one year after the successful cloning of Dolly the sheep, while “To Test or Not to Test” is used more than 3,500 times (most of these are as terrible as you’d expect, but occasionally there are gems like “To test or NOD-2 test: what are the questions?”).

Peak Shakespeare was surely reached in the multi-Shakespeare-referencing “Breast cancer screening: all's well that ends well, or much ado about nothing?”

Besides the Bard, Goodman found 244 allusions to Hans Christian Andersen’s The Emperor's New Clothes. If you can name it, the emperor has worn it, from isodose curves to “the lateral ligaments of the rectum”.

One paper incorporates both Andersen and Shakespeare (“Mentorship – Is It a Case of the Emperor's New Clothes or a Rose by Any Other Name?”), while “Evidence-Based Practice: Sea Change or the Emperor's New Clothes?” simultaneously pushes my ocean cliché button and ticks the Andersen box.

Goodman argued that such titles are a learned behaviour and that we are likely to see new allusions emerge over time.

He seems to be correct. Science writer Ed Yong noticed that paper titles are already playing around with “Winter is coming”, a quote from Game of Thrones. Although even here there is the odd gem – eg, “Winter is coming: hibernation reverses the outcome of sperm competition in a fly”.

While similar studies have been made of movies and songs in paper titles, nobody has yet taken on the likely considerable task of documenting the inclusion of classic novels.

There are doubtless plenty of examples here too. Indeed, biochemist Eva Ansen weaved 41 paper titles alluding to Steinbeck’s Of Mice and Men into a poem, producing some powerful rhyming couplets in the process:

Of mice and men: the evolving phenotype of aromatase deficiency.

Of mice and men: an introduction to mouseology or, anal eroticism and Disney.

Certain classics lend themselves to lazy exploitation. A Tale of Two Cities can become a tale of two pretty-much-anythings, from perspectives and depressions to caves and auto plants, while a Catch-22 might present itself to anything from special education reform to “Amphibian conservation and wetland management in the upper Midwest”.

Plug the title of any classic into your academic search engine of choice for hours [minutes] of fun.

 Glen Wright tweets at @AcademiaObscura

You've reached your article limit

Register to continue

Registration is free and only takes a moment. Once registered you can read a total of 6 articles each month, plus:

  • Sign up for the editor's highlights
  • Receive World University Rankings news first
  • Get job alerts, shortlist jobs and save job searches
  • Participate in reader discussions and post comments
Register

Have your say

Log in or register to post comments

Featured Jobs

Lecturer in Econometrics UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW
Lecturer in Applied Economics UNIVERSITY OF GLASGOW
Reader of Law UNIVERSITY OF PORTSMOUTH

Most Commented

question marks PhD study

Selecting the right doctorate is crucial for success. Robert MacIntosh and Kevin O'Gorman share top 10 tips on how to pick a PhD

Pencil lying on open diary

Requesting a log of daily activity means that trust between the institution and the scholar has broken down, says Toby Miller

India, UK, flag

Sir Keith Burnett reflects on what he learned about international students while in India with the UK prime minister

Application for graduate job
Universities producing the most employable graduates have been ranked by companies around the world in the Global University Employability Ranking 2016
Construction workers erecting barriers

Directly linking non-EU recruitment to award levels in teaching assessment has also been under consideration, sources suggest