Birmingham union members vote to boycott Dubai campus

Universities minister Sam Gyimah says student exchanges should continue, despite UAE’s jailing of Matthew Hedges

十一月 22, 2018
Dubai skyline

Members of the University and College Union (UCU) at the University of Birmingham have voted to turn down teaching at the institution’s Dubai campus, amid growing concern about threats to academic freedom in the United Arab Emirates.

The vote came a day after Matthew Hedges, a Durham University PhD student specialising in Middle Eastern politics, was jailed for life in the UAE after being found guilty of spying – a sentence that has provoked a furious backlash from British politicians and researchers.

However, Sam Gyimah, the UK’s universities minister, has urged institutions not to cut their ties with the Arab state.

The Birmingham vote, which means that staff will refuse to cooperate with the Dubai campus unless explicitly required to by their contract, follows concerns for the rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender staff and students in the UAE, and possible exploitation of migrant workers during the next phase of construction.

Staff will turn down teaching unless explicitly stated in their contract, refuse to volunteer materials for the delivery of modules, and turn down requests to participate in exam boards.

James Brackley, president of the UCU branch at Birmingham, said: “UCU members at the University of Birmingham are outraged at the sentence of Matthew Hedges and the university’s refusal to address the serious issues we have raised regarding its campus in Dubai.

“The university must now engage meaningfully with us to provide guarantees about the safety and academic freedom of staff and students in Dubai.”

Mr Hedges had been detained in the UAE since May and held in solitary confinement for five months before being convicted of spying for or on behalf of the UK government.

Mr Hedges’ wife Daniela Tejada has said that her husband is “not a spy, he is a researcher”, and has criticised the response of the UK’s Foreign Office to his detention as “ineffective”.

Durham has put a temporary moratorium on all non-UAE national student researchers travelling to the UAE until the reasons for Mr Hedges’ detention are fully established. Ms Tejada has argued that academics should be given diplomatic immunity to protect them abroad.

But Mr Gyimah argued that student exchanges between the UK and the UAE should continue, although he added that this was “not in any way to suggest that we approve of what has happened in [Mr Hedges’] case”.

“Student exchange involves not just our students going to those countries but students from those countries coming here, and I think students from those countries coming here and experiencing what it means to live in a fully functioning democracy can only be a good thing,” Mr Gyimah said.

“So if you were to boycott these exchange programmes it is potentially undermining our ability to positively influence what is going on in these countries by getting their [potential] future leaders to understand, experience and share the values that we hold dear.”

A Birmingham spokesman said that the university was “surprised and concerned” by Mr Hedges’ detention.

“We have always respected the views of those staff who do not wish to engage with our Dubai campus and have been clear from the outset that opportunities to work in Dubai are optional for all staff, and indeed in most instances staff have actively applied for these roles,” the spokesman said.

He added: “Our priority is the safety of our staff and students and the delivery of a high-quality educational experience in locations across the world and we will continue to review and update our advice as appropriate to ensure this remains the case.”



  • 注册是免费的,而且十分便捷
  • 注册成功后,您每月可免费阅读3篇文章
  • 订阅我们的邮件
Please 登录 or 注册 to read this article.

Reader's comments (1)

Exchanges between students are of course valuable. But Mr Gyimah's argument holds no water in this case: in extreme security states - which the UAE has sadly become in the course of the past decade as Abu Dhabi's increasing security obsession has obliterated any genuine autonomy of the six other emirates in this sphere - it matters not at all what these young people think, as there is no room for their independent views. The only view that matters is that of the leader (in this case MbZ) and his closest associates. After all, two of the most prominent examples of people who obtained their PhDs in the UK include those who are now executing or publicly justifying the treatment of Matt Hedges (my former student at Exeter): (1) the Attorney General, Dr Hamad Al-Shamsi, who got his PhD at Exeter (and thus is a fellow alumnus of Matt's); (2) the Minister of State for Foreign Affairs, Dr Anwar Gargash, who got his PhD at Durham (Matt's current university). One could add to this key individuals who obtained their PhDs at US universities - including the doyen of UAE political science, but current stand-out defender of the authorities in this case, Dr Abdulkhaliq Abdullah, who got his PhD at Georgetown - my own current institution. Quite possibly none of these people personally believe these measures are the right thing - although it is conceivable that they have over time come to adopt the regime's line - but that's immaterial, too, since they would never be allowed the autonomy to express anything else, or even the option to remain silent. By all means continue to accept UAE students in UK institutions; but that does not require broader partnerships; nor sending staff or students to the UAE.